Thursday, August 13, 2009

Thursday Oil Market Round-Up

Click on all images for a larger image


The main question with the oil market right now is this: is the market forming a double top? Clearly the price is currently at/near its previous peak. In addition, the RSI has printed a lower top (so far) and the the MACD's level is close to the level of the first peak. Prices are just above the 50 week EMA -- a level which they failed to hold a few months ago before the summer driving season.


The daily chart adds more credence to the double top theory. Notice that prices are about the same level as the first peak. But notice that both the RSI and MACD are at far lower levels then the previous peak. That is very interesting from a technical level as it indicates the second peak is technically weaker than the first peak.

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Fed Sees Stabilization

From the Federal Reserve:

Information received since the Federal Open Market Committee met in June suggests that economic activity is leveling out. Conditions in financial markets have improved further in recent weeks. Household spending has continued to show signs of stabilizing but remains constrained by ongoing job losses, sluggish income growth, lower housing wealth, and tight credit. Businesses are still cutting back on fixed investment and staffing but are making progress in bringing inventory stocks into better alignment with sales. Although economic activity is likely to remain weak for a time, the Committee continues to anticipate that policy actions to stabilize financial markets and institutions, fiscal and monetary stimulus, and market forces will contribute to a gradual resumption of sustainable economic growth in a context of price stability.

Economists See US and Global Recovery

From Bloomberg:

Recovery from the worst recession since the 1930s has begun as President Barack Obama’s fiscal stimulus -- derided as insufficient and budget-busting months ago -- takes effect, a survey of economists indicated.

The economy will expand 2 percent or more in four straight quarters through June, the first such streak in more than four years, according to the median of 53 forecasts in the monthly Bloomberg News survey. Analysts lifted their estimate for the third quarter by 1.2 percentage points compared with July, the biggest such boost in surveys dating from May 2003.

“We’ve averted the worst, and there are clear signs the stimulus is working,” said Kenneth Goldstein, an economist at the Conference Board in New York.

The new projections, following better-than-anticipated reports on manufacturing, employment and home construction, echo gains in investor confidence that have propelled the Standard & Poor’s 500 Stock Index to its high for the year. A rebound may help cushion declines in Obama’s approval ratings, political analysts said.

“The fact that people for the first time in over a year are starting to look at some glimmers of hope plays to the prospect of some strength in the stimulus,” said Susan Molinari, a Republican strategist in Washington who advised Rudy Giuliani during his presidential nomination campaign in 2008.


This echos a point Paul Krugman made recently:

A few months ago the possibility of falling into the abyss seemed all too real. The financial panic of late 2008 was as severe, in some ways, as the banking panic of the early 1930s, and for a while key economic indicators — world trade, world industrial production, even stock prices — were falling as fast as or faster than they did in 1929-30.

But in the 1930s the trend lines just kept heading down. This time, the plunge appears to be ending after just one terrible year.

So what saved us from a full replay of the Great Depression? The answer, almost surely, lies in the very different role played by government.

Probably the most important aspect of the government’s role in this crisis isn’t what it has done, but what it hasn’t done: unlike the private sector, the federal government hasn’t slashed spending as its income has fallen. (State and local governments are a different story.) Tax receipts are way down, but Social Security checks are still going out; Medicare is still covering hospital bills; federal employees, from judges to park rangers to soldiers, are still being paid.


And consider this:

From Bloomberg:

Confidence in the world economy surged to a 22-month high in August on signs the worst global recession since World War II is coming to an end, a Bloomberg survey of users on six continents showed.

The Bloomberg Professional Global Confidence Index jumped to 58.12 this month from 39.13 in July. It is the first time the reading exceeded 50, which means optimists outnumber pessimists. A measure of U.S. participants’ confidence in the world’s largest economy rose to 47.3 from 29.5, the survey showed.

“It’s clear the recession is over and some kind of recovery is underway,” said Nick Kounis, chief European economist at Fortis Bank Nederland Holding NV in Amsterdam, and a regular survey participant. “We have the biggest monetary and fiscal stimulus policy in history, globally, and we’re starting to see it work. Probably the next debate will be about how strong and sustainable the recovery is.”

The MSCI World Index has increased 12 percent in the past month and President Barack Obama said last week’s unexpected drop in the U.S. unemployment rate indicates the worst may be over. Nobel Prize-winner Paul Krugman said Aug. 10 that the world, now in a “rough stabilization” mode, has averted another Great Depression.


I pretty much agree with these statements. First, I think the economy is clearly bottoming. Here are some relevant charts to that matter:



Initial unemployment claims are still dropping



The rate of job losses are decreasing



ISM manufacturing is increasing



New homes sales have bottomed



Existing home sales have bottomed



The New York and Philly Fed are increasing



Retail sales have bottomed



Real PCEs have bottomed

2.) I think an interventionist government is a primary reason for the fact that we are not in the abyss. The Fed's actions -- while controversial -- saved the financial system from collapsing. They also helped to steady the credit markets. The government stimulus also helped to pump money into the economy, adding some much needed momentum to the economic situation.

The Market is At Very Important Technical Levels



The market is currently at the 38.2% Fibonacci retracement level from the 2007 peak. Also remember we're at an important fundamental time -- we're waiting for the Fed to issue it's policy statement. Funny how things line up like that, isn't it?

Wednesday Commodities Round-Up


On the industrial metals weekly chart, notice the MACD and RSI are still rising. All the EMAs are moving higher, the 10 week EMA is about to cross over the 50 week EMA and the 20 week EMA is about to follow. Prices have been moving higher since the first quarter and they have been consolidating gains along the way.


The daily chart better shows the price action. Notice the rally is not too steep. Instead, it is fairly gentle. In addition we can better see how prices have consolidated gains as they have moved higher. Finally, notice the position of the EMAs -- the shorter EMAs are above the longer EMAs, all the EMAs are rising and prices are above the EMAs.


Agricultural prices are also in an uptrend, but a far less strong one. Instead of a solid move higher, prices are more or less in the middle of an upward sloping channel. The MACD and RSI are also giving mixed signals. Finally, the EMAs are jumbled instead of having a clear direction. In short, this is a chart looking for a direction.


The main issue with the daily chart is that prices have jumped higher but have failed to to anything since the move. The MACD and RSI are signaling strength. In addition, the shorter EMAs are moving higher and the 10 day EMA is about to cross over the 50 day EMA. But frankly, the chart just doesn't feel bullish to me.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Today's Markets



Click for a larger image

I wish I was good enough at music editing so I could put the phrase "waitin' on the Fed" to ZZ Tops Waitin' on the Bus. Because that's what the market is really doing. While prices have dropped we're still clearly in a Fibonacci are.

As for support levels, consider the daily chart:


My primary concern with the chart is the Fibonacci levels -- they are pretty low right now. But, a sell-off would be helpful right now in the long run.

How Bad Are Things Out There In the Economy?

From IBD:

Norwalk, Conn.-based Priceline (PCLN) said it earned $2.02 a share, excluding special items such as stock-based compensation, in the second quarter. That's up 30% from the year-earlier quarter and way above the $1.75 consensus estimate of 15 analysts polled by Thomson Reuters.

.....

Rivals Orbitz (OWW) and Expedia (EXPE) recently reported second-quarter earnings that shattered analyst views by 16 cents and 7 cents, respectively, but their results continue to lag Priceline's. Orbitz saw its sales fall 19% from a year earlier, while Expedia's sales fell 3% and profit fell 5%.


Part of the reason why these companies are successful is they are generally pretty good at delivering low prices. However, people are buying from these companies. I find that point very interesting given the current environment.

Cash for Clunkers and Inventories

From the WSJ:


More than $1.03 billion has already been paid out to cover the 245,384 vehicles traded-in under the program designed to replace gas guzzlers with more fuel-efficient vehicles, according to the U.S. Department of Transportation. Another $2 billion is now being funneled into the program, which is slated to run through November.

Starting last year, the Big Three U.S. auto makers began to cut back production to cope with swelling inventories as consumers skipped purchases amid the recession. During the bankruptcies of GM and Chrysler, both auto makers idled their plants, further reducing supply. Heading into July, it appeared auto makers finally had control of their inventories.

That changed as the government's clunkers program set off a flurry of buying. Even consumers who didn't qualify for the program made purchases. Under the program, formally known as the Car Allowance Rebate System, a customer who trades in a vehicle rated at 18 miles per gallon or less qualifies for a government voucher of $3,500 or $4,500 to buy a new car rated at 22 mpg or more. The allowance goes to the dealer, who must scrap the old vehicle.

With that story in mind, consider this chart:


The depth of the inventory correction is very deep. As a result inventories are incredibly lean. Any meaningful bump in consumption will possibly lead to shortages as producers ramp up production. I don't know how much this is going to be part of the recovery story. I do however think it will play a part.


Treasury Tuesdays


Click for a large image

The treasury market has three big problems: a rallying stock market, massive supply and an increased risk appetite. All of these are adding to the downward pressure on the Treasury market.

Prices are currently in a downward sloping channel with a decreasing RSI and MACD. Also note the very bearish orientation of the EMAs -- the shorter EMAs are below the longer EMAs and all the EMAs are moving lower.

Also note the riskier parts of the bond market are rising.


Click for a larger image

The investment grade bond market is rallying, as is



The junk bond market

Given the supply coming onto the market, I would not expect a rally in the Treasury market.

Monday, August 10, 2009

Today's Markets



Click for a larger image

Not much in the way of price action today. Prices were down .18% on the SPYs. As the daily chart below shows, notice that prices opened lower, rallied, fell and then wound up back where they started.


Click for a larger image.

The main action today came in conservative/defensive areas. The TLTs were up 1.25%, the XLVs were up .8% and the IEFs were up .64%. My guess is traders are playing it safe until the Fed releases the minutes on Wednesday. Ultimately this is good for the bulls as it allows the market to cool off right now; the market is pretty over-extended and it needs to let some profits get taken -- or at least move sideways for a bit. Notice how the RSI is peaking right now:


Also note how the MACD is approaching a sell signal:

From Invictus: I'm Still Not Convinced

So we got a “green shoot” on Friday in the form of “only” a -247,000 print on the nonfarm payrolls and a drop in the employment rate to 9.4% (mostly due to folks just leaving the labor force). When we got a -223,000 (initial) print for April in May 2001, and the unemployment rate was 4.5%, we got commentary like this (via the NY Times): ''These numbers mean that the economy is right now at about zero growth,'' said Peter Hooper, chief domestic economist for Deutsche Bank North America. ''I don't see much of anything positive in this report.'' But that was in the days when -200k (or more) NFP print was considered unacceptable, I guess. Now it’s a cause for celebration.
Here’s the employment situation updated through Friday relative to previous recessions:


(Source: St. Louis Fed)

Maybe it’s just me, but that chart doesn’t exactly make me feel like dancing a jig, even knowing it’s a lagging indicator. Still not liking the glide path, especially given the fact that we’re now some 20 months removed from the recession’s starting point (December 2007).

But let’s move on and talk about what sort of recovery we might eventually see. Bonddad and I recently wrote about why the consumer will probably not be leading the economy out of recession (forgive me for saying so, but I think it was a really good piece).

To add to that file, I’ve replicated below a chart published last week by former ML Chief Economist David Rosenberg, who continues to do stellar work at his new shop, Gluskin Sheff:

Various US GDP Components: Average Contribution to Change in The First Year of Economic Recovery

(percentage points)


(Source: BEA.gov. Average of four quarters following quarter in which NBER determined recessions ended.)

In other words, the consumer – through Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) – contributes 3.2 percentage points to GDP in the first (usually fairly strong) year of post-trough economic recovery.

That’s simply not going to happen this time around, in my opinion, and here’s another vivid illustration to make that point. PCE are running well below even the worst previous recession of the post-war era:


PCE should be on a decent uptrend by now – just look above at the “average” and “highest” performance. They’re not (uptrending), and it’s simply too important (and too big) a component of recovery to think we’re going to get very far without it. This is why I worry that Q3 is going to be a one-hit wonder.

Among the reasons PCE aren’t on the upswing is this: We know that there’s no organic income growth:


(Source: BEA.gov)

Further, the American consumer is shedding credit like never before. In another – but much less publicized – report released last Friday, we saw that consumer credit, on a year-over-year basis, has contracted by a record $71 billion dollars:


(Source: Federal Reserve)

Given that credit was responsible for fueling much of our recent economic growth, its decline continues to signal a frugal future.

If there was a “green shoot” to be found in Friday’s report it was in Aggregate Weekly Hours, though it was so small as to be almost imperceptible. I’ll highlight it for you below:


NBER Business Cycle Dating Committee member professor Jeffrey Frankel watches this metric very closely, and this is what he had to say: “The latest numbers show that the length of the workweek has begun to rebound from its record low of two months ago. As a result, the BLS reports that total hours worked in the economy did not decline at all in July, for the first time since the financial meltdown of last September. One never wants to read too much into a single report, especially one subject to revision. But when today’s labor news is combined with a variety of other data, it looks likely that the economy is finally at or near the turning point.”

To say that whatever it is the economy’s doing right now is “fragile” is, I think, to understate the case. I continue to look for a driver of growth going forward, and as yet have not found it. When the aforementioned David Rosenberg left Merrill Lynch, he penned some rules to remember. Among the most important, in my opinion, is #12: “Get the US consumer right and everything else will take care of itself.” That is why I remain steadfastly focused on the U.S consumer, who is 70% of U.S. GDP and about 20% of GDP worldwide – because no one drives business like the U.S. consumer. And until the U.S. consumer is back on his feet, it’s hard to imagine an environment that will produce any more than subpar growth.

On an unrelated note, the also aforementioned professor Jeffrey Frankel had this to say about the work Obama has done to address the economic disaster he inherited: “In any case, in light of the difficult circumstances, I think Obama has done amazingly well. […] In my view, overall, Obama has gotten far more things right than wrong. He has bravely proposed things that most sensible economists — whether Republican or Democrat — have long favored. Proposing is not always the same as enacting; there is the matter of Congress. But he has tried to get them passed, and has tried to do it in a bipartisan way.”

I would tend to agree.



Market Mondays


Click for a large image

The market has rallied 15.5% since the mid-July. Also note how steep the line is -- line's of that amplitude don't last. Prices have already broken through the upward sloping trend line and are moving sideways. For the bulls, an ideal situation this week is for sideways movement or a fall to a natural support level like the 10 day EMA or SMA. To that end, we have the Fed this week which usually provides a natural slowing down as markets wait for the Fed's decision. While it's doubtful we'll see any move on interest rates (and probably won't for some time) the statement's tone is very important.

Saturday, August 8, 2009

The Song of the Dead Black Swan

Historically initial jobless claims (i.e., applications to begin payment of unemployment benefits) have been a leading indicator of recessions when they go up, and recoveries when they go down. After peaking on a smoothed 4 week average basis at 659,000 in early April of this year, they delined slowly through June and then rapidly in July. The current reading is 559,000, or a decline of 15% from the peak.

But the BLS keeps statistics not just of initial claims, but also unemployment of less than 5 weeks duration, 5-14 weeks, 15-26 weeks, and finally, 27 weeks duration and up. And those statistics show a consistent pattern as recessions end: the initial claims peak first and are most leading; as you go longer out into the series, the data tends to get less "noisy" and smooths out, but it also becomes more and more lagging, until the 27+ weeks data always peaks well after recessions are over. In the graphs below, in which initial claims are in blue, unemployment for 5-14 weeks old are in red, an 27+ are in green, notice that blue peaks first, then very quickly afterward red, and with a significant lag, green.

The first graph is for the 1974-75, 1980 and 1981=82 recessions:


This second graph is for the 1991 and 2001 recessions and the "jobless recoveries" thereafter:


And this final graph shows our own recession:


During July, it was contended by some pessimists, including on a Receommended diary here, that the event was a "Black Swan"; that the decline only was because of early shutdowns of auto plants, so laid off autoworkers weren't putting in for benefits in July. It was further contended that once that seasonal effect wore off by about the third week of July, new jobless claims would rapidly rise again through their April highs. Unadjusted jobless claims were increasing, we were told, and were the "real" trend for those who wanted to tell the truth.

But instead of rising, non-seasonally adjusted claims (shown in red in the graph below) have declined by 200,000. Seasonally adjusted claims have also continued to decline on a smoothed 4 week basis (in blue):



Now let's go back to the previous graph. Note in particular the sharp decline in the red line in the graph of our current recession: that is claims that were between 5-14 weeks old in July. In other words, this is unemployment that began no later than June, and therefore cannot include the supposedly downward distortion by auto layoffs that didn't happen in July, and yet still steeply declined.. This data confirms that July's steep decline in new unemployment claims was the "real thing" and not just a statistical blip. In other words, the Black Swan is well and truly dead. It is not just pining for the Autralian outback. It has passed on. It is no more. It has ceased to be. It has expired and gone to meet its maker. It's a stiff. Bereft of life, it rests in peace. It's metabolic processes are now history. It's kicked the bucket, it's shuffled off this mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the choir invisible. In short, THIS IS AN EX-BLACK SWAN.



But in its dying swan song, it has provided us with further information about what might be ahead. Because as I previously pointed out, unemployment data for the period of 5-14 weeks duration is still slightly leading, and also has less noise.

First of all, in the past, the most the 5-14 week average has ever declined without heralding the imminent end of a recession is 7.5% in 1970. It is now down 17.5%.

Secondly, go back and look at the graph covering the period 1974-82. Recoveries from those recessions, two of which were quite deep, were "V: shaped and featured strong job growth. Notice how the red line declined steeply and consistently.
Next, look at the graph of the 1991 and 2001 "jobless recoveries". Notice that the red line does not decline very steeply at all. In fact, the maximum it has turned down during the entire duration of those "jobless recoveries" was -11% and -14.5%, respectively.
Finally, look at the graph of our own recession. Note that the red line is again declining steeply, just as it did after the 1974-1982 recessions, already off 17.5%, just through the end of June. And because of those aforementioned auto plant closures and start-ups, it is almost certainly going to reported as having declined considerably further when the data is next released in a month.

In summary, the Song of the Dead Black Swan tells us not just that the recession is nearly over, but suggests that at least in the next few months, there could be actual job growth, more robustly than almost anyone suspects.

Friday, August 7, 2009

Weekend Weimar and Beagle

It's that time of the week.

See you on Monday.




July Leading Economic Indicators blow through important inflection points

- by New Deal democrat

As I have previously said, this week we did receive 4 very important new data points on Leading Economic Indicators. Including the late reports from June, here is my latest estimate for July Leading Economic Indicators:

The yield curve is still wildly positive +0.3
Stocks 3 month gain is worth +0.2
New home sales are worth about +0.1
Jobless claims are worth about +0.2

Durable goods subtract -0.2
Consumer sentiment subtracts -0.1
Real M2* has been trending slightly negative, so -0.1

*For someone who formally apologized to Milton Friedman about the Fed's role in the Great Depression, it is astonishing that Ben Bernanke has let real M2 turn negative in the last few months.

So far, that is a +0.4. Adding in this last week's new data points, we get:

average hours in manufacturing+0.2
ISM deliveries +0.1
consumer nondurables +0.2

That brings the net gain for June revisions and July to +0.9!

This means:
(1) 4 months of positive LEI in a row. Three in a row usually is enough to signal a turnaround.
(2) over a 6 month period, 7 indicators are positive, 2 are negative, 1 is unchanged. Unless catastrophe strikes, one of the two negative indicators will turn positive in the next two weeks. That will make it 8-1-1. In the past, 9 of 10 positive for 6 months has always coincided with economic growth.
(3) the LEI are now positive YoY. This also in the past has coincided with economic growth.

This is consistent with economic growth beginning possibly as early as last month.

The coincident indicators will tell us the turn has actually occurred. Of the 5 important ones, real retail sales is already positive. Aggregate hours worked was just reported as unchanged from June to July. Industrial production only fell 0.1 in June, and is projected to rise 0.1 in July. That leaves payroll employment, just reported today at -247,000, as the laggard. We will probably have to wait for actual payroll growth (which could start as early as September), to be confindent that the recession really is over.

Now that is a good way to end the week!

Payrolls Drop 247,000; Job Market Shows Improvement

From the BLS:

Nonfarm payroll employment continued to decline in July (-247,000), and the unemployment rate was little changed at 9.4 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. The average monthly job loss for May through July (-331,000) was about half the average decline for November through April (-645,000). In July, job losses continued in many of the major industry sectors.


In looking at the report, first note the unemployment rate has been steady now for three months:



In an of itself, that is an encouraging; it indicates there is a possibility the unemployment rate is topping. Adding further evidence the that theory is the general trend of overall job losses:



Note there are two areas. The first shows that maximum job losses occurred in the fourth quarter of last year and the first quarter of this year. However the trend since the beginning of this year is for a continuing decline in the number of job losses per month. As the chart above shows that trend has now been in place for six months, indicating we have a firm trend in place.

But there are other reasons indicating things are improving:

The number of persons working part time for economic reasons (sometimes
referred to as involuntary part-time workers) was little changed in July at 8.8 million. The number of such workers rose sharply in the fall and winter but has been little changed for 4 consecutive months.


This is good news as it indicates the level of people who are forced to work part time not because they want to but because they have to has been level for the last 4 months.

Let's combine this information with the initial unemployment claims information from yesterday:



Note that the four week moving average of initial claims continues to move lower. Also note that according to the Department of Labor the unadjusted (non-seasonally adjusted) numbers fell by 48,000 last week. This is on top of a loss of 90,000 two weeks age and 60,00 next week. In short -- the unadjusted number of initial unemployment claims has dropped by over 200,000 in the last three weeks.

Bottom line: this is a good report.

LEI #4: July Manufacturing hours worked up strongly

- by New Deal democrat

This morning we got the 4th of 4 readings of Leading Economic Indicators this week. In July, average hours worked in manufacturing increased 0.3 hours to 39.8 hours. This is a very positive reading, indicating that manufacturing is beginning a robust recovery (by contrast, last autumn during the collapse hours were declining as much as -0.3/month).

This means that all 4 readings of LEI's this week have been strongly positive:
- on Monday, the ISM manufacturing index showed economic expansion in new orders and deliveries.
- on Wednesday, nondurable (consumer) goods new orders increased a strong 2.7%, to the highest reading in over half a year.
- on Thursday, initial jobless claims declined to 550,000 the second lowest reading in over 6 months, and a data point completely unaffected by the "noise" about early auto plant shutdowns.
- today, hours worked in manufacturing likewise increased to the strongest reading in the last 6 months.

I will follow up later with a post on what the July reading for the aggregate LEI's is likely to be, but suffice it to say, this week's grand slam of strongly positive leading data bodes very well for a return to positive economic growth in the next 3 months.

----------

In addition to the -247,000 loss of jobs in July (still the best reading in 11 months), which confirms the trend towards job gains in the next few months, the aggregate total hours worked in private industry in July held even (0.0). This is important since it, like nonfarm payrolls, is a coincident indicator used by at least one member of the NBER to delineate the end of recessions.

Update: Oh, and amid all the good news, I forgot to add that the unemployment rate actually dropped 0.1 to 9.4%.
A blowout good report!

Forex Fridays


The weekly chart shows the strength of the downtrend -- even when the dollar made a second top both the MACD and RSI printed lower. Also note that prices consolidated in a triangle pattern as they fell and then moved lower. Finally, the 10, 20 and 50 day EMA are all moving lower, the shorter EMAs are below the longer EMAs and prices are below all the EMAs.


The daily chart shows the consolidation and fall in more detail. Notice the triangle consolidation pattern followed by the move lower. Also note the EMA picture -- the shorter EMAs are below the longer EMAs, prices are below all the EMAs and all the EMAs are moving lower. Also note the 20 day EMA provided upside resistance for prices last week.

Bottom line -- this is a bearish chart.

Thursday, August 6, 2009



Click for a larger image

Prices are moving sideways after their strong move higher. Notice that prices and EMAs are still in a strong/bullish position -- prices are above all EMAs, the shorter EMAs are above the longer and all the EMAs are moving higher. However -- tomorrow we have the employment report which will be a very important number.

Stay tuned ....

From Invictus: I'm Not Convinced

Let’s get straight to the most recently updated charts of four critical NBER recession-dating metrics:

First up, Employment, on which we’ll get a new read Friday. If today’s ADP print is any indication, we’re still looking at a nonfarm jobs loss of roughly 300,000. Here’s the chart through last month’s print (including data on previous recessions):



Industrial Production is still declining, and has certainly not troughed or signaled any uptrend whatsoever.




Real Retail Sales are flatlining, probably about the best that can be said for any of the metrics the NBER looks at:



Real Income, which we just got, is not a pretty picture, as it continues



If we peel back the numbers a bit on Real Income, what we see is not encouraging. Private Wages & Salaries – the most important component of income – have declined by 6.1% year-over-year. Dividend income has been cut by one fifth, interest income by 4.5%. Proprietors’ income is down 8.0%. As we have seen previously, Personal Current Transfer Receipts (i.e. money from the government) has grown by 10.2% over the past year. Bottom line: No organic income growth. Is this the stuff of which sustainable recoveries are made?



Finally, let’s take another look at Aggregate Weekly Hours (professor Jeffrey Frankel’s favorite metric). Still declining, and at a record low last time it printed.



There can be little doubt that companies increase hours before they hire new employees. It’s just good business sense. There is HUGE slack in the labor market.

Some other things we know:

Q3 GDP will print positive, of that there’s little doubt. Could be 3% for all I know. Recall this, however (all data as recently revised by BEA): Q1 of 2008 printed -0.7%. President Bush signed his $150 billion dollar stimulus plan and Q2 printed +1.5%. When the adrenaline wore off, Q3 printed -2.7%, and we all know what happened after that. The point is that much of what is happening now – cash for clunkers, for example – is simply pulling forward future sales into this quarter and consequently weakening future quarters. Similarly, the $8,000 first-time home buyer credit has the same effect. How much can we pull forward, and what happens if/when these programs end (which they will eventually have to)?

We also know that the consumer – 70% of GDP – is still under significant strain and will likely remain so for quite some time to come (delinquencies, defaults, foreclosures, bankruptcies all still at troubling levels). We know that there are six applicants for every job opening. We know that unemployment is headed to double digits (lagging, yes, but problematic nonetheless). We know that there’s a huge overhang of housing inventory. Lastly, we know that Capacity Utilization is at an all-time low.

I still remain unconvinced that the recession has “officially” ended, and would certainly not draw that conclusion solely on positive Q3 GDP. There’s a reason the NBER analyzes a host of data, and through my lens most of it has not yet signaled a trough. In any event, it will certainly not feel like a recovery for most of America.

Note on recession tracking charts: The charts plot four main economic indicators tracked by the NBER dating committee [I added Aggregate Hours]; each series is indexed to 100 at the start of the recession. For industrial production, employment, and real retail sales, the average series includes the 10 recessions starting with the November 1948 business cycle peak. For real income, the average starts with the April 1960 peak. For additional information, see the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Economic Synopses, 2009, No. 4.