Wednesday, November 18, 2026

The autumn skies have turned gloomy for housing

 

 - by New Deal democrat


The housing market, along with corporate profits and real retail sales per capita, is one of the three nonfinancial, or “real world” long leading indicators, that is of added importance for whether the US economy continues in expansion or falls into recession.

Earlier this year housing construction had been most consistent with an economy coming out of a recession than going in to one. That was derailed by the decision of the Buffoon in Washington to start the Iran war, which caused inflation, and interest rates to increase. In particular, mortgage rates came close to a new multi-year high last month:



Which, unsurprisingly, has led to a sharp decline in mortgage applications, housing sales, and new permits and starts. While this morning’s report indicated that the relatively noisy housing starts (blue) for October increased 9.4% to 1.309 million units annualized, the three month average was the lowest since this past winter. The less volatile and slightly more leading permits (gold) declined -7.4% to 1.295 million. The least volatile metric of all, single family permits (red, right scale) declined -8.7% to 772,000:



Total permits made a new post-pandemic lows, and perhaps even worse, single family permits are the lowest in almost 10 years except for the two months of the pandemic lockdowns and two months at the end of 2022. Further, permits are down -15.% from their recent peak in February this year, and single family permits are down -16.9% from their similar peak. 

All three of these metrics had been trending essentially sideways since the summer of last year. But this month, permit are down -8.9% and single family permits are down -12.9%. Only the volatile starts measure is higher, by 2.8%:



This doesn’t mean housing is forecasting a recession yet since, while I won’t bother with the graph this month, in the past these three metrics have generally been down -10% or more YoY to be consistent with the onset of a recession. Per the above, however, single family permits are down more than -10% from their recent peak, so this raises the first yellow caution flag that we are probably going to have to restart watching for a recession signal in the near future.

Now let’s update the several “last shoes to drop” in the housing sector. In particular, housing units under construction (blue), which had been giving a recovery signal earlier this year by rising from its lows, something that it typically does after the end of a recession, has now stalled out again, declining -1,000 to 1.272 million units annualized. And the even later shoe to drop, employment in residential construction (orange, right scale), may have reversed its recent increasing trend as well:



In summary, while real retail sales continue to sail on, and the outlook for corporate profits is only partly cloudy, to paraphrase an apt seasonal lyric from the late Gordon Lightfoot, for housing the proverbial skies have turned gloomy.