Wednesday, April 15, 2020

Coronavirus dashboard for April 15: Infections lower but deaths make new daily high


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 14) 

Highlights in italics. There were no significant developments yesterday. Deaths rose to a new daily high, but probably reflected the recording of the data after the weekend.

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +27,091 to 609,685 (vs. 35,219 peak on April 10)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 5% (vs. 6% for the past week, and 4% on April 13)

The number of new infections has clearly declined from a recorded peak last week.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 25,668, increase of +2,299 day/day (new daily high)

  • Rate: increase of 10% day/day vs. average of 11% in past week
  • Number of tests: 146,614, up +17,500 day/day (vs. 163,769 peak on April 9)
  • Ratio of positive tests to total: 5.7:1

US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no changes in past 24 hours 
Below are the States that have not gone to lockdown orders:
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND^, NE, UT*^, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • East Coast consortium: 7 States: CT, DE, MA, MD, NJ, NY, PA, RI
  • West Coast consortium: 3 States: CA, OR, WA
  • Also under development: 1 State: UT
  • Midwest consortium*: 3 States: MI, MN, WI
*procurement of medical supplies only
Summary for April 14

Here’s how we stand (meaningful new developments in italics): 
  • About 95% of the total US population remains under total lockdown.
  • In States with no lockdowns, while South Dakota has emerged as a new hotspot, its governor has denied the lack of a lockdown has played a role. Meanwhile, a mall in Nebraska plans to reopen.
  • The number of both daily new infections appears to have plateaued in the past week, while deaths made a new high.
  • The number of daily tests has stalled at about 140-150,000. As a result, we likely have been missing a large percent of new infections. My personal suspicion is that the actual number of total infections in the US is between 2-5x the official number.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so, and is using a haphazard, secret, and likely corrupt method of distributing vital medical equipment.
  • In the absence of federal action, 14 States are either coordinating in making purchases of the necessary equipment, and/or to develop their own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. Yesterday, Michigan’s governor indicated she was speaking with other Midwestern governors about developing such a consortium similar to the Northeast and West Coast consortiums.
  • Some private companies are developing technologies or equipment to be used in a “test, trace, and quarantine” regimen. For example, Google and Apple have premiered an app under development that will trace coronavirus contacts. 
  • Trump backed off his claims of “total authority” to “open up” States’ lockdowns.

March retail sales and industrial production: not nearly as awful as might have been expected


 - by New Deal democrat

Both March retail sales and industrial production were reported this morning. After employment, these are the two biggest reports I follow each month. 

In particular, normally I spend a lot of time parsing the long and short leading aspects of retail sales - especially as it tends to shortly lead employment. I don’t think that is particularly useful to resume yet. Industrial production, by contrast, is the King of coincident indicators.

Since the economic effects of the coronavirus pandemic only hit in the second half of March, I don’t think we are seeing the full impact in these numbers. But let’s take a look at what they show so far.

Both were objectively awful. But neither one was as awful as could easily have been expected. Both knocked off about the last 2.5 years of growth.

First, here’s real retail sales, both excluding (blue) and including (red) food services. I include the former because, of course, restaurants have been all but obliterated by the lockdowns:


Including food services, real retail sales were down -8.8% from their January peak. Excluding food services, they were down -6.3% from that peak. 

While in normal times that would be awful, that both maintained over 90% of their pre-coronavirus levels is cautiously encouraging news. Partly this is probably because of early March hoarding, partly because some services, like grocery stores, have to remain open, and partly because there is probably a big surge in online shopping.

Turning to industrial production, we see a similar story. Total production declined -5.4% from February, and manufacturing declined -6.3%:


Both of these were not nearly so bad as might have been anticipated.

I expect worse to come when this month’s reports are released in May. But for now, the takeaway is “less awful,” and I’ll take it.

Tuesday, April 14, 2020

Huge initial jobless claims numbers point to massive 25,000,000 loss in April jobs report


 - by New Deal democrat

This is something I’ve been meaning to post since the last three weeks of huge, 3- and 6,000,000-plus numbers of initial jobless claims.

There is a general correlation between initial jobless claims and payrolls. Even in the best months, 1,000,000 total claims for initial benefits might be filed. But that is offset by 1,200,000 or more new hires for new jobs - I.e., for example, a net gain of 200,000 jobs during the month.

If we take the gain of roughly +.2% monthly in net jobs in a good jobs market, we can create a pretty decent historical correlation between the percent change in new jobless claims (blue, inverted in the graph below) and net jobs in the monthly payrolls report (red):


Noisy, but the correlation generally holds. Of course, the above graph stops before the month of March 2020, when all hell broke loose (and will make future historical graphing of initial claims and jobs a real challenge).

So here is the past year, through last week’s initial claims report:


The 4 week average of initial jobless claims suggests that the April jobs report is going to show something like a 25% loss in the entire jobs market! Since going into the crisis there were about 150,000,000 jobs in the US, a 25% loss equates to about -30,000,000 jobs.

Truly staggering.

P.S.: By the way, under any econometric election model you can find, such a loss if not quickly reversed portends disaster for the presidential candidate of the incumbent party.

Coronavirus dashboard for April 14: two consortiums of States formed


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 13) 

The big news yesterday was the formation of 2 consortiums of States, on the East and West Coasts (something I have advocated and predicted for a month), to develop and jointly implement plans to “test, trace, and quarantine” as part of detailed plans to reopen their economies, completely sidestepping the inert federal government.

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +25,004 to 582,594 (vs. 35,219 prior peak on April 10)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 4% (vs. 7% for the past week, and 5% on April 12)

Yesterday marked the lowest number of new infections in over a week, and the smallest % increase since early March.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 23,369 up +1,450 day/day

  • Rate: increase of 7% day/day vs. average of 12% in past week
  • Number of tests: 129,114, down -11,112 day/day
  • Ratio of positive tests to total: 4.5:1

US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no changes in past 24 hours 
Below are the States that have not gone to lockdown orders:
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND^, NE, UT*^, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • East Coast consortium: 7 States: CT, DE, MA, MD, NJ, NY, PA, RI
  • West Coast consortium: 3 States: CA, OR, WA
  • Also under development: 1 State: UT
  • Midwest consortium*: 3 States: MI, MN, WI
*procurement of medical supplies only
Summary for April 14

Here’s how we stand (meaningful new developments in italics): 
  • About 95% of the total US population remains under total lockdown.
  • The number of both daily new infections and deaths appear to have plateaued in the past week.
  • The number of daily tests has stalled at about 140-150,000. As a result, we likely have been missing a large percent of new infections. My personal suspicion is that the actual number of total infections in the US is between 2-5x the official number.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so, and is using a haphazard, secret, and likely corrupt method of distributing vital medical equipment.
  • In the absence of federal action, 14 States are either coordinating in making purchases of the necessary equipment, and/or to develop their own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan.
  • Some private companies are developing technologies or equipment to be used in a “test, trace, and quarantine” regimen. For example, Google and Apple have premiered an app under development that will trace coronavirus contacts. 
  • Trump has claimed “total authority” to “open up” States’ lockdowns which if done would likely create a Constitutional crisis, as several States have already indicated that they would refuse to follow a (likely Unconstitutional) federal “order.”

Sent from my iPad

Monday, April 13, 2020

Coronavirus dashboard for April 13: Plateauing and stasis


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 13). The bottom line is that infections and deaths appear to have plateaued, while there has been no progress towards any “test, trace, and quarantine” regimen that is the necessary next step; and to the contrary Trump appears to be bound and determined to try to reverse lockdowns anyway.

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +27,584 to 557,590 (vs. 35,219 prior peak on April 10

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 5% (vs. 8% for the past week, and 6% on April 11)

Yesterday marked the lowest number of new infections in 7 days, and the smallest % increase since early March.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 21,919 up +1,564 day/day

  • Rate: increase of 8% day/day vs. average of 13% in past week
  • Number of tests: 140,226, up +28,983 day/day
  • Ratio of positive tests to total: 4.8:1

US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no changes in past 24 hours 
Below are the States that have not gone to lockdown orders:
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND^, NE, UT*^, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs - no changes
  • Under development: 6 States: CT, MA, MD, NJ, NY, UT

Summary for April 13

Here’s how we stand (meaningful new developments in italics): 
  • About 95% of the total US population remains under total lockdown.
  • The number of both daily new infections and deaths appear to have plateaued in the past week.
  • The number of daily tests has stalled at about 140-150,000. As a result, we likely have been missing a large percent of new infections. My personal suspicion is that the actual number of total infections in the US is between 2-5x the official number.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so, and is using a haphazard, secret, and likely corrupt method of distributing vital medical equipment.
  • In the absence of federal action, various States are either coordinating in making purchases of the necessary equipment, and/or to develop their own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan.
  • Until States or the federal government implement a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine,” lockdowns cannot be lifted.
  • Some private companies are developing technologies or equipment to be used in a “test, trace, and quarantine” regimen. For example, Google and Apple have premiered an app under development that will trace coronavirus contacts. 
  • Any attempt to “open up” the lockdowns with testing so far behind - aside from creating a Constitutional crisis, assuming the States would refuse to follow a (likely Unconstitutional) federal “order” - would be yet another disaster, as we could expect the disease to rapidly re-accelerate towards its former rate of 35% growth in new infections daily.

Sunday, April 12, 2020

A thought for Sunday: a brief history of Republics anticipates Trump


 - by New Deal democrat

I just finished reading William R. Everdell’s “The End of KIngs: A History of Republics and Republicans,” which was originally published in 1983. It was interesting to read a book that treated Watergate as recent history!

I want to write at more length about this book, but for now, consider the following excerpts and consider how they relate to our current situation.

In his chapter about the Weimar Republic, Everdell writes: 

The “Reichsprasident” of Weimar was nothing but a kaiser in reserve.... Not only was his constituency national and democratic, like that of Louis Napoleon in 1848, his term, at seven years, was longer and he could be reelected indefinitely. He had not need to stage an illegal coup like Napoleion’s in 1851, because by the contittution’s famous Article 48 he was empowered, in times of what he determined to be “public disturbance,” to take “necessary measures.” These included the overruling of state laws, the abrogation of all civil liberties, the making of national laws by decreee, the execution of law by the army, and the establishment of exceptional courts and jurisdictions.
Two thin hedges protected parliamentary republican power from the overwhelming strength of the kaiser in reserve. One was ... impeach[ment].... The other was the provision of a veto, by majority vote of the Reichstag, of all presidential decrees under Article 48.” [but the President could prorogue the parliament, making it imposssible for them to do so]..... 
Adolf Hitler had formed [the Nazi party]... on the three simple principles of ... tyranny. The first was the fuhrerpriinzip, a popular version of the old Kaiser ideal according to which every member obeyed HItler without question and was reciprocally identified with him. The two others were complete unscrupulousness with regard to tactics and complete opportunism with regard to program..... 
Hitler ... had to promise nearly every class and interest precisely what it wanted. The Nazis ... offer[ed] labor peace to businessmen, benefits to workers, uniforms to militarists, and anything to anyone, unless of course he were Jewish.
It’s as if Trump treated Hitler’s campaign, and his use of emergency powers, as a “how to” manual.
——

In his chapter on historic clashes between the US Senate and presidents, he writes,
If presidents ever do succeed in establishing a monarchy in America, the last institution to stand against them will probably be the Senate.
(P. 271) 
Mr. Everdell, meet Mitch McConnell.

Following NIxon’s re-election in 1972,
  

At the Office of Economic Opportunity that January, an unconfirmed Acting Director set about dismantling the agency....
By April, Attorney-General Kleindienst was explaining that executive privilege protected any member of the executive branch from the grim necessity of talking to Congress or a court. ... Nixon ... announc[ed] just after the election and again in March that he would veto any spending bill he thought excessive, and that if Congress overrode him he would simply “impound” or refuse to spend the funds ....
The press, too, was on notice of approve the president. In December 1972, an unconfirmed Nixon appointee named Clay Whitehead had threatened local television stations with Federal Trade Commission action if they continued to broadcast the “elitist gossip” of the network news.

(Pp. 294-5)
Were Trump and William Barr taking notes?

Abbreviated Coronavirus dashboard for April 12: fundamentally, still flying blind


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 11) 

This is an abbreviated version, covering just the essentials.

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +28,391 to 530,006 (vs. 35,219 prior peak on April 10)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 6% (vs. 8% for the past week, and 8% on April 9)

Yesterday marked the lowest number of new infections in 6 days, and the smallest % increase since early March. Note the source graph I am using does not come from the usual source, which developed a glitch.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 20,355, up +1,867 day/day

  • Rate: increase of 10% day/day vs. average of 14% in past week
  • Number of tests: 153,514 down -9,255 day/day, new daily high for non-“pending” tests
  • Ratio of positive tests to total: 4.6:1


Summary

While it is pretty clear that the lockdown in place for 95% of the US population is having its desired effect, what is *NOT* clear is whether the plateau is real, or just reflects the stalling of daily testing at roughly 140,000. For the past 5 days, the number of new cases has increased or decreased depending on whether the number of total tests has increased or decreased. In fact one day ago the number of new cases INcreased even though the number of tests decreased. 

In other words, fundamentally we are still flying blind. My suspicion is that the actual number of total infections in the US has been between 2x to 5x the 530,000 “official” count above.

Needless to say, any attempt to “open up” the lockdowns with testing so far behind - aside from creating a Constitutional crisis, assuming the States would refuse to follow a federal “order” - would be yet another disaster, as we could expect the disease to rapidly re-accelerate towards its former rate of 35% growth in new infections daily.

A slight glimmer of light is that Dr. Fauci gave an interview yesterday in which he suggested that a test for seroconversion - I.e., resistance to the disease via antibodies subsequent to infection - might be widely available in a few weeks. If I were forced to go to a “plan B” it would involve opening up the economy to those who have seroconverted and do not reside with those who have not seroconverted. 

Saturday, April 11, 2020

Weekly indicators for April 6 - 10 at Seeking Alpha


 - by New Deal democrat

My Weekly Indicators post is up at Seeking Alpha..

As you can imagine, most of the numbers are horrible.

Clicking over and reading will bring you as up to date as you can be on the economy, and as usual rewards me a little bit for my efforts.

Coronavirus dashboard for April 11: new high in daily infections as testing falls further behind



 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 10) 

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end. Significant new developments are indicated in italics.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com) 
  • Number: up +35,219 to 501,615 (vs. 33,958 prior peak on April 9) 

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 8% (vs. 9% for the past week, and 8% on April 9)

The exponential growth rate began to fall from 35% on March 24. In the past two weeks it was in a slowly decelerating trend of between -0.5% and -1%/day. In the past 5 days that has nearly come to a halt.
It’s not clear if this is a shortcoming in State lockdowns which appeared to have been working, or a shortcoming in testing, but I strongly lean towards the latter explanation.
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 18,488, up +2,089 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 13% day/day vs. average of 15% in past week
  • Number of tests: 153,514 down -9,255 day/day, new daily high for non-“pending” tests
  • Rate: decrease -6% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 17,631 vs. 17,631 on April 9 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +8% vs. Tests -6% day/day
Result: The rate of testing appeared to be catching up a little bit to the spread of the virus, but stalled again in the past week at about 140,000/day. It remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day, and is falling further behind. 

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 153,514 new tests vs. 34,204 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 4.5:1 

In South Korea, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 4.5:1 is not only far behind, but has gotten worse in the past 7 days. Along with a number of others, I am very concerned that insufficient testing is hiding the increasing spread of the virus. That the percentage of positive results to total tests keeps rising only heightens that concern — i.e., we are not finding new potential breakouts. Yesterday’s pattern - decreasing tests with the highest ever number of positives - is the worst situation.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no changes in past 24 hours
  • ***Total lockdown: 43 States, 306.7 million, 92.4%
  • ***Business lockdown: 2 States (KY, MA^^) 14.4 million, 4.3%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND^, NE, UT*^, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State
^^mandatory quarantine of persons attending Easter services(!)
There have been no meaningful changes in the past day.
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • Under development: 6 States: CT, MA, MD, NJ, NY, UT

Summary for April 10
The best public health strategy is that of a temporary total lockdown to turn the new infection rate negative while the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment to treat existing cases and for a massive “test, trace, and quarantine” to be put in place.

Here’s how we stand (meaningful new developments in italics): 
  • About 95% of the total US population is under total lockdown.
  • Yesterday the US recorded a new high in daily new infections. 
  • Mandatory lockdowns have brought the rate of growth in new infections down to just below 8%/day, but this deceleration has stalled in the past week. Most likely, this is because of the next bullet point.
  • The number of daily tests appears to have stalled again at about 140-150,000. As a result, we appear to be missing an increasing number of actual new infections.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown, and in fact appears to want to “open up” society on or by May 1, even without a testing regimen in place. 
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so.
  • In the absence of federal action, various States are either coordinating in making purchases of the necessary equipment, and/or to develop their own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan.
  • Until States or the federal government implement a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine,” lockdowns cannot be lifted.
  • Kentucky’s governor has announced that people who disregard the State’s social distancing order to attend Easter services will be placed in quarantine.
  • Google and Apple have premiered an app under development that will trace coronavirus contacts

Friday, April 10, 2020

(Abbreviated) coronavirus dashboard for April 10


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 9). Real life intrudes a little, so I have omitted the State by State analysis, and abbreviated the conclusions.

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end. Significant new developments are indicated in italics.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +33,958 to 466,636 (vs. 33,787 prior peak on April 4)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 8% (vs. 10% for the past week, and 8% on April 8) 

The exponential growth rate began to fall from 35% on March 24. In the past two weeks it was in a slowly decelerating trend of between -0.5% and -1%/day. In the past 4 days that has nearly come to a halt.
Nevertheless, State lockdowns have been working.
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 16,399, up +1,904 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 13% day/day vs. average of 14% in past week
  • Number of tests: 162,769 up +21,460 day/day, new daily high for non-“pending” tests
  • Rate: increase +15% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 17,631 vs. 17,228 on April 8 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +8% vs. Tests +15% day/day
Result: The rate of testing appeared to be catching up a little bit to the spread of the virus, but stalled again in the past week at about 140,000/day. Even with yesterday’s 20,000+ increase, it remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day, and is falling further behind. 

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 162,769 new tests vs. 34,326 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 4.7:1 

In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 4.7:1 is not only far behind, but has gotten worse in the past 4 days. I am very concerned that we face a situation similar to what we had a month ago, where insufficient testing was hiding the spread of the virus. That the percentage of positive results to total tests keeps rising only heightens that concern — i.e., we are not looking for new potential breakouts. Yesterday’s pattern - where an increase in testing of 14% led to an increase  positive diagnoses of 12% , only reinforces that position. 

Summary for April 10
There are 3 items of significance that happened in the past day:
  • The number of new diagnoses made a new high, superseding the recent April 4 high
  • A 15% increase in testing, to a new high ex-“pending” results, netted a 12% increase in new diagnoses. In other words, about all the increase in testing did was show how many new infections we have been missing. 
  • Trump was forced to backtrack on ending funding for community test centers, but again put forward an early end to lockdowns (which the federal government does not have the power to force on the States anyway) which, if implemented, would only result in renewed exponential spread.

Consumer prices sharply decline in March: keep your eye on wages


 - by New Deal democrat

This morning we got some monthly economic data that will be actually valuable to watch throughout this Coronavirus Recession: consumer prices. That’s because during recessions, consumer price growth decelerates, as does wage growth, which continues to decelerate well after the recession bottoms out.

Since monthly changes in inflation are closely correlated with the gas prices, let’s start by comparing the two:


Gas prices declined -8.5% during March. Unsurprisingly, consumer prices followed suit, declining by -0.4%.

Next, let’s compare overall consumer inflation (blue again) with consumer inflation ex-energy (red), since prior to the past two recessions the latter had increased by 2.5% or more YoY:


We were on the cusp of that 2.5% threshold just before this recession hit. Note that inflation ex-energy tends to follow overall inflation with a slight lag. If gas prices remain depressed, we can expect this “core” inflation measure to decelerate substantially as well. This is par for the course during a recession.

What is much more worrisome to me is whether wage growth, which came close to completely stalling even nominally during and after the Great Recession, with 16 months of wage growth of less than +0.1%, as shown below, might actually tip into deflation this time around - a concern that I have repeated numerous times during the past expansion:


Here is what YoY wage growth (black) looks like in comparison with consumer prices ex-energy (red):


Expect wage growth to decelerate sharply almost immediately. Should it ever tip into negative territory, that would open the door almost instantaneously to a vicious wage-price deflationary spiral, the type of which was last seen during 1929-32. Keep your fingers very crossed.

Thursday, April 9, 2020

Coronavirus dashboard for April 9: Are new cases peaking? Or is a lack of testing failing to pick up continued spread?



 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 8) (NOTE: significant new developments in italics)

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +32,509 to 432,438 (vs. 33,787 peak on April 4)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 8% (vs. 10% for the past week, and 9% on April 7)

The exponential growth rate began to fall from 35% on March 24. It now looks like in the past 10 days or so it has been in a new, slowly decelerating trend, declining by between -0.5% and -1%/day. Here’s a good graph of that trend if a few days old:

State lockdowns appear to be working.
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 14,405, up +1,874 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 15% day/day vs. average of 16% in past week
  • Number of tests: 141,309 down -4,796  vs. 155,063 recent peak on April 6
  • Rate: decrease -3% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 17,228 vs. 16,557 on April 7 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +8% vs. Tests -3% day/day
Result: The rate of testing appeared to be catching up a little bit to the spread of the virus, but has stalled again in the past week at about 140,000/day. It remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day, and is falling further behind. 

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 141,309 new tests vs. 30,570 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 4.6:1 

In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 4.6:1 is not only far behind, but has gotten worse in the past 4 days. I am very concerned that we face a situation similar to what we had a month ago, where insufficient testing was hiding the spread of the virus. That the percentage of positive results to total tests keeps rising only heightens that concern — i.e., we are not looking for new potential breakouts.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no changes in past 24 hours
  • ***Total lockdown: (SC joined yesterday) 43 States, 306.7 million, 92.4%
  • ***Business lockdown: 2 States (KY, MA) 14.4 million, 4.3%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND^, NE, UT*^, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State

There have been no meaningful changes in the past day.
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • Under development: 6 States: CT, MA, MD, NJ, NY, UT

Summary for April 9
Almost every public health authority who has weighed in has advocated the “Sledgehammer, then Scalpel” approach of a temporary total lockdown, during which time, as the infection rate of growth hopefully moves to flat, the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment is surged. Once enough is in place, a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine” can be put in place as the lockdown is lifted.

Here’s how we stand (meaningful new developments in italics): 
  • About 95% of the total US population is under total lockdown.
  • Mandatory lockdowns, first implemented on Statewide bases 20 days ago, appear to be paying off, as the daily rate of increase in new cases is now in single digits. The peak in new daily infections might only be about 10 days away - and may possibly have already happened on April 4)
  • BUT the number of daily tests appears to have stalled again at about 140-150,000, and is far short of of what is necessary. As a result, we may be missing an increasing number of actual new infections, meaning that the slowdown in diagnosed infections might be an artifact of the lack of testing, rather than a true result.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so.
  • To the contrary, the Trump Administration has announced an end to support of community testing.
  • California’s governor has announced a plan for the States to coordinate in making purchases of the necessary equipment.
  • Massachusetts has begun to develop its own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. The governor of Connecticut announced two days ago that it, NY and NJ will also work on a regional plan. Utah and Maryland are also said to be developing their own plans.
  • Until States or the federal government implement a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine,” lockdowns cannot be lifted.
  • Contrarily, North Dakota, a State with no lockdown, lifted part of its interstate travel restrictions yesterday.