Wednesday, January 13, 2010

About the Wall Street Hearings

Today we will see more theater regarding Wall Street. I've been silent on this issue because so far the entire exercise has been pointless. Here's how you deal with the problem.

Regarding wall street firms, you have two choices:

1.) Allow big institutions to exist, but regulate them with a regulator who has teeth and is willing to use its teeth.

or

2.) Reinstate Glass Steagall

Regarding derivatives, put them (all) on a regulated market. Personally, I would argue for the CBOE, but that's just me. Others are available and equally qualified.

Regarding consumer credit issues, eliminate the really hyper-fancy loans (like option ARMs and IOs) as a product for consumers. Consumers get a choice: a 15 year mortgage or a 30 year mortgage. Simple.

This isn't rocket science -- it's actually pretty straight-forward.

The basic problem is both parties are represented by idiots. Back when there were calls for nationalizing all the banks I wrote several pieces arguing against it. The basic reason is this: yes the current crop of bankers are incompetent. But -- do you really want Chuck Schumer and Mitch McConnel in charge of a bank? If you think it's bad now -- wait until these idiots start to make loan decisions.

So we'll see lots of grand-standing, camera hogging, and lots of terms thrown around that the speaker doesn't understand what they just said, and then nothing will be accomplished.

Next.

These Guys Get Paid To Be Stupid

GM will use -- trucks to grow:

General Motors Co. has freed up cash to fund a major update of its full-size pickups, a bet that consumers and businesses will resume buying trucks after a long lull in sales.

Chairman and Chief Executive Edward E. Whitacre Jr. has agreed to fund the move, said GM product chief Tom Stephens. The remodeling could cost the company close to $1 billion, a person familiar with the matter said.

GM, which had relied on full-size pickups such as the Chevrolet Silverado for a major portion of its U.S. revenue and operating profit, had put off redesigning the trucks as its finances collapsed and it underwent a government-backed bankruptcy reorganization last year.

Now, unlike in the 1990s truck boom, the company plans to revitalize its pickup line at the same time it invests heavily in small, fuel-efficient cars as well as in the electric Chevrolet Volt due later this year. At this week's big Detroit auto show GM displayed its new Chevy Cruze, which it hopes will be its first strong contender in compact cars in decades.

Trucks sales sagged in the past two years after gasoline spiked to $4 a gallon in 2008 and home sales -- a big driver of truck purchases by contractors and builders -- collapsed amid the recession.

Yes, they have other products coming out -- but you just have to wonder what the thought process behind this move. Guys -- do you really think oil is going to stay low as the economy starts to grow?

China Starts to Exit Stimulus

From the WSJ:

China, which for more than a year has been pushing its banks to pump out cash to offset the global downturn, abruptly reversed course Tuesday, in the clearest sign yet that Beijing has turned its attention to controlling the repercussions of that credit explosion.

The People's Bank of China said it will raise the percentage of deposits that banks must keep in reserve and can't lend, a shift intended to stave off inflation and the asset bubbles that can accompany it.

Economists called the central bank's move a significant, sooner-than-expected step away from the giant stimulus effort that began in late 2008.

.....

"The reserve requirement often seems to function as a leading indicator, partly because it's a good signaling point to the markets," said Mark Williams, senior China economist at Capital Economics Ltd. in London. "From that perspective, it's a turning point."

.....

Also on Tuesday, for the second time in a week, the central bank raised the yield it pays on its short-term bills. That makes the debt securities more attractive for banks to buy, a move designed to siphon cash out of the financial system.

.....

While China's early recovery underpinned the global economy, the country is facing the fallout from its success earlier than other major economies. Recent news that China overtook Germany as the world's largest exporter has sharpened calls for Beijing to lift the value of its currency, a move that would make its exports more expensive. China also faces mounting protectionist pressures.

Meanwhile, Beijing's stimulus policy allowed companies to gorge on easy credit and speculate on properties and stocks -- not necessarily productive investments. Banks could find themselves facing questions about whether loans could become uncollectable.

The easy lending may have also encouraged wasteful spending: The government recently said that over 106,000 officials were punished last year for misconduct, including abuse of economic-stimulus money.

This is a very important development for several reasons.

1.) China has been a primary driver of the recovery. If they are slowing down their lending program it indicates there is concern the negatives of this program now outweigh the positives.

2.) China's growth has provided a floor for economic activity over the last year -- basically, so long as China was still spending money then goods would flow. While the recent moves are not fatal to this idea, they do indicate a slowdown is more and more possible.

3.) Unlike the US which has been growing at a slow rate with excess capacity, China has been growing at a strong clip. That means the possibility of inflation is higher. Hence, the need to be more vigilant now.

Wednesday Commodities Round-Up


A.) Prices have been in an uptrend for several months.

B.) Prices have consolidated gains as they have moved higher.

C.) Yesterday prices broke their upward trend.

Trend breaks provide important information. First, we know that something has fundamentally changed in the way the traders look at a security. An uptrend trend says traders see higher prices (duh). But when that trend changes something has changed in the way traders look at that security. Now -- the question is what changed yesterday?

China's surprise move Tuesday to increase the amount of funds banks need to keep on hand likely reflected its growing unease over the outlook for inflation, but analysts were divided over whether the move marks a complete change in stance for monetary policy.


This means it will be harder for Chinese firms -- who are major commodities consumers -- to purchase raw materials.

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Today's Market


A.) Prices retreated to the top upward sloping trend line on higher volume.


A.) Prices retreated but are still within the ascending triangle pattern. Note the 10 day EMA has curved lower, but not in a fatally bad move.



A.) Prices are resting right above technical support.

All of these charts have the same common pattern: prices have moved lower and are either at technical support or are contained within a pattern.

More on Employment



The initial unemployment claims continues to drop. Also note the rate of the drop is on pace with the post 1982 recession.


Those unemployed less than 5 weeks has been dropping since the beginning of the year. But the current level is still above the level of 2005-2007 indicating we're still above the historical norm.


The number of unemployed 5-14 weeks has topped out, but is still about 1.2 million above the norm established in 2005-2007.


The number of unemployed 14-25 weeks also appears to have topped out, but is about 1.6 million over the norm of 2005-2008.


The number of people unemployed over 27 weeks continues to increase. This number is over 4 million above the norm of 2005-2008.

The above series of charts should be read as a time progression -- first people are laid off then the move through the various time periods until (regrettably) they are unemployed for over 27 weeks.

The good news in these series is that the shorter numbers (initial unemployment claims and under 5 weeks unemployed) have been decreasing for some time. The less than 5 week number has been decreasing since the beginning of the year and the initial unemployment claims number has been decreasing since the mid/late spring. Unfortunately, because of the rate of job loss during the height of the recession there are still a ton of people unemployed. Let's revisit some numbers to illustrate that point.


Note that at the end of 2009/early 2009 the US lost at least 600,000 jobs/month. We have also learned that the BLS added an additional ~800,000 of job losses to the total amount of jobs lost. While I am sure this will ignite another round of ill-informed conspiracy theories about employment, the reality is that measuring the economy is an incredibly difficult task -- especially during a massive financial shock. As a result, revisions are to be expected.

Let's add two more charts:


Note that construction jobs have dropped by over 1.5 million and


Manufacturing jobs have dropped by over 4 million. That means the vast majority of job losses are attributable to two areas of the economy.

What makes both of these areas of jobs losses concerning is this: the vast majority of these jobs probably aren't coming back. Construction benefited from the housing bubble. Considering the high rate of vacancies and existing home inventory there is no reason to start building en mass again. And note that after the 2001 recession manufacturing didn't come back either. The primary reason is technological advances -- the country saw an increase in overall production and productivity on a declining labor force.

So -- let's sum up.

1.) The employment numbers continue to move in the right direction. Initial unemployment claims continue to drop, leading to a continuing drop in the 5 week and under category. The other categories of time unemployed have topped out save the 27 weeks plus category.

2.) A large percentage of job losses come from construction and goods production industries. Construction jobs aren't coming back because they were caused by the housing bubble. Manufacturing jobs will probably suffer from the same circumstances that hit them in the 2001 expansion -- increased productivity leading to increased production at the expense of a declining workforce.

Update:

David Altig at the Atlanta Fed offers this chart:



And these points:

After growing during the 1980s and 1990s, the aggregate labor force participation rate (the percentage of the working-age population active in the labor market employed or looking for work) peaked in the late 1990s and is currently at levels last seen in the 1980s. But this change pales in comparison to changes in labor force participation among America's youth (those folks in the 16- to 24-year-old age range).

During the 1980s participation in the labor market for youth averaged around 68 percent, a rate noticeably higher than for older individuals. The youth participation rate declined sharply to a level at or below the level for older individuals prior to the 1990–91 recession and then remained relatively stable during the 1990s. However, over the past decade youth labor market participation has been on a steep downward trend and currently stands at a little over 55 percent, compared with about 67 percent for older individuals. Moreover, the most recent recession has seen youth participation rates decline at a rate similar to that seen in the early 2000s. In contrast, the labor force participation by individuals over 24 years of age has varied much less, implying that the decline in youth labor force participation has been a major contributor to the reduction in the overall rate of labor force participation (see the above chart).

.....

The big change appears to be that those in school have become increasingly less attached to the labor market. The percentage of school enrollees aged between 16 and 24 who are also participating in the labor market was relatively stable between 1989 and 1998 at around 51 percent. However, labor market participation by those in school declined between 1999 and 2008 from 50 percent to 42 percent. In contrast, labor force participation by those aged between 16 and 24 not enrolled in school has declined only modestly—from 82 percent to 80 percent between 1989 and 2008.

There are economic returns (benefits less costs) to both labor market experience and education. The decreased attachment to the labor market of school enrollees likely reflects, at least in part, factors such as the increased lifetime economic returns to education relative to alternative uses of time. As such, a widening wage premium on education is probably an important influence on youths' schooling choices, including schooling intensity. An example would be enrolling in educational programs during the summer instead of looking for summer employment.

Who's Unemployed?

The following information is from Table A-7 of the BLS employment report:

Ages 16-19 have a 27.1% unemployment rate while those aged 20-24 have an unemployment rate of 15.6%.

Let's think about those numbers for a minute. Teens are unemployed in high numbers. While that is not good, it's also important to remember this point: these are people who should be in school -- that is, being a student is their primary job. Is a high unemployment rate for this group fatal?

I am more concerned about the 20-24 year unemployment rate because there is a large population of people who I am assuming need some work in college. But again, this is an age when the primary job (at least through age ~22-23) is education rather than employment.

The unemployment rate for 25-34 is 10.2%. Simply put, that is a terrible number.

The unemployment rate for 35-44 is 8.8%, the unemployment rate for 45-54 is 7.9% and the rate of 55%+ is 7.1%.

I'm beginning to wonder if the numbers for each group over 35 is what a new structural unemployment will look like? That is -- are we moving into a period when higher unemployment rates are standard? Most of us have gotten use to the idea that 5% is "full employment". But is that level even possible or realistic right now?

Table A-4 adds a few important details:

Unemployment rate by educational achievement level:

High-school drop-out: 15.3%
High-School graduate: 10.5%
Some college/associate: 9%
Bachelor's Degree and Higher: 5%

This ties in with an article on the front page of today's WSJ:

The downturn that started in December 2007 delivered a body blow to U.S. workers. In two years, the economy shed 7.2 million jobs, pushing the jobless rate from 5% to 10%, according to the Labor Department. The severity of the recession is reshaping the labor market. Some lost jobs will come back. But some are gone forever, going the way of typewriter repairmen and streetcar operators.

Many of the jobs created by the booms in the housing and credit markets, for example, have likely been permanently erased by the subsequent bust.

"The tremendous amount of economic activity associated with housing, I can't see that coming back," says Harvard University economist Lawrence Katz. "That was a very unhealthy part of the economy."

Treasury Tuesdays


A.) Prices peaked a bit above 91 in late November. Since then they have been dropping steadily.

B.) Prices first bounced off resistance in mid-December, then broke through on their second move lower

C.) Prices are currently consolidating in a triangle pattern which can be a reversal or continually patter. Also note that prices are right against the downward sloping trend line that starts from the late-November peak.

D.) Prices are bearishly aligned -- all are moving lower and the shorter and below the larger. Also note that the 10 day EMA has provided resistance for prices for the last few days.

Monday, January 11, 2010

Today's Market



Click for a larger image

A.) Prices opened higher but quickly fell to the 10 and 20 minutes EMAs.

B.) Prices found twice support twice at the previous day's high.

C.) At the end of the session, prices rose just beyond the 61.8% Fibonacci number, then fell to the 10 minute EMA.

Is the Drop in the Not In the Labor Force Number Really the Beginning of the Baby Boomer Rertirement Wave?

Silver Oz has posted a very thought-provoking piece on the "not in the workforce" issue currently embroiling some in the economic blogsphere. I'm going to add onto that with an explanation of what "not in the labor force" means. This will lead to two conclusions. First, many people don't know what the statistics mean. Secondly , is also appears that a large number of people are choosing to leave the workforce, indicating we are possibly witnessing the beginning of the baby boomer retirements.

Let's start with the broadest measure of the workforce:

Labor force measures are based on the civilian noninstitutional population 16 years old and over. Excluded are persons under 16 years of age, all persons confined to institutions such as nursing homes and prisons, and persons on active duty in the Armed Forces. As mentioned previously, the labor force is made up of the employed and the unemployed. The remainder—those who have no job and are not looking for one—are counted as "not in the labor force." Many who are not in the labor force are going to school or are retired. Family responsibilities keep others out of the labor force.

So, we have three groups of people: employed, unemployed and not in the labor force. If you go to table A-1 on the latest BLS release and look at the top area you will see all of these areas:


Click for a larger image.

Now, take out your calculator for a minute. Note that civilian labor force = the total number of employed and unemployed. Then notice that the civilian labor force and the not in the labor force = the civilian non-institutional population.

For the BLS, an employed person is:

Persons 16 years and over in the civilian noninstitutional population who, during the reference week, (a) did any work at all (at least 1 hour) as paid employees; worked in their own business, profession, or on their own farm, or worked 15 hours or more as unpaid workers in an enterprise operated by a member of the family; and (b) all those who were not working but who had jobs or businesses from which they were temporarily absent because of vacation, illness, bad weather, childcare problems, maternity or paternity leave, labor-management dispute, job training, or other family or personal reasons, whether or not they were paid for the time off or were seeking other jobs. Each employed person is counted only once, even if he or she holds more than one job. Excluded are persons whose only activity consisted of work around their own house (painting, repairing, or own home housework) or volunteer work for religious, charitable, and other organizations.

While an unemployed person is:

Persons aged 16 years and older who had no employment during the reference week, were available for work, except for temporary illness, and had made specific efforts to find employment sometime during the 4-week period ending with the reference week. Persons who were waiting to be recalled to a job from which they had been laid off need not have been looking for work to be classified as unemployed.

With me so far? Good. The real issue is what does "not in the labor force" mean -- because that is what is causing all the controversy. Let's look in a bit more detail about what "not in the labor force" means:

A series of questions is asked each month of persons not in the labor force to obtain information about their desire for work, the reasons why they had not looked for work in the last 4 weeks, their prior job search, and their availability for work. These questions include:

1. Do you currently want a job, either full or part time?
2. What is the main reason you were not looking for work during the LAST 4 WEEKS?
3. Did you look for work at any time during the last 12 months?
4. LAST WEEK, could you have started a job if one had been offered?

These questions form the basis for estimating the number of persons who are not in the labor force but who are considered to be "marginally attached to the labor force." These are persons without jobs who are not currently looking for work (and therefore are not counted as unemployed), but who nevertheless have demonstrated some degree of labor force attachment. Specifically, to be counted as "marginally attached to the labor force," individuals must indicate that they currently want a job, have looked for work in the last 12 months (or since they last worked if they worked within the last 12 months), and are available for work. "Discouraged workers" are a subset of the marginally attached. Discouraged workers report they are not currently looking for work for one of four reasons:

1. They believe no job is available to them in their line of work or area.
2. They had previously been unable to find work.
3. They lack the necessary schooling, training, skills, or experience.
4. Employers think they are too young or too old, or they face some other type of discrimination.

Additional questions about persons not in the labor force are asked during each household's last month of its 4-month tenure in the sample rotation pattern. These questions are designed to collect information about why these people left their previous jobs, when they last worked at a job or business, and whether they intend to look for work in the near future.

The central issue with the "Not in the Labor Force" definition is the BLS wants to figure out if someone is really not in the work force or if they want to work but for some reason can't find a job. Here is a table from the monthly unemployment report (table A13) that shows the "not in the labor force" number and its various sub-parts:


Click for a larger image.

Now -- let's do some basic math. In December the seasonally adjusted "not in the labor force" number was 83,865,000 while the "persons who currently want a job" were 6,306,000 or about 7.5% of the "not in the labor force number." This percentage was 6.8% a year ago. So the number has increased, but is still an incredibly small percentage of the "not in the labor force number." In other words, the "not in the labor force" number is composed primarily (as in over 90%) of people who don't want to work. What this means is that last month people did not disappear into some statistical black hole -- they in fact decided to leave the work force. And we know this because 7.5% of the people who "aren't in the work force" want a job. Also remember the definition above of "not in the work force:"

Many who are not in the labor force are going to school or are retired. Family responsibilities keep others out of the labor force.

So -- some people have decided to go back to school -- which is a good thing. And some people have decided to retire -- also a good thing. And some have decided to help with their family -- also a good thing.

Now -- go back to table A-1. From November to December, the "not in the labor force" number increased 843,000. However, over the same time period the "Persons who currently want a job" -- a subset of the "not in the labor force" statistic -- only increased by 263,000. That means 580,000 left the work force but don't want a job. From the definition above, these people could have retired, gone back to school or helped out with family matters. But the point is that about 68% of the people who left the work force last month don't want a job. Again note there is no conspiracy to send people in a giant meat grinder a la Pink Floyd. People made a decision to leave the work force.

As Silver Oz notes, over the last 12 months the "not in the labor force" number has increased by 3.4 million but the "persons who want a job" number has only increased 795,000. Put another way, 2.6 million people have left the work force but don't want a job. That's something that has been completely lost in the "debate" about this number. Additionally, we have seen a large increase in the number of people applying for social security benefits:

Applications for Social Security benefits rose almost 50 percent more than expected this year because of the recession, according to the federal retirement program.

“We are seeing a significant increase in both retirement and disability applications as a result of the recession,” said Mark Lassiter, a Social Security spokesman.

The 150,000 extra retirees may add to the financial pressure on the entitlement program. In May, Social Security trustees said expenses would exceed revenue beginning in 2016, one year earlier than their previous forecast.

.....

The Social Security Administration had projected an increase of 315,000 applicants for the 12 months ending Sept. 30 partly because the first baby boomers -- those born right after World War II -- are starting to retire.

The actual increase was higher. Agency statistics show that 2.57 million people requested benefits, up from the 2.10 million applications received during the previous 12 months. That’s an increase of 465,000, or 47 percent higher than the expected rise.

All of this tells us the the US labor force is shrinking which is born out by this chart of the labor force participation ratio:


Remember that the US employment population is broken down into various subsets. The biggest group is the civilian non-institutional population -- which is the practically everybody in the country over 16 YO. Then there is the civilian labor force which is all the people who are employed + all the people who are unemployed. To get the labor force participation rate we divide the civilian labor force (all employed and unemployed people) by the total number of people who could be working (the civilian non-institutional population). Notice that this number started to steadily increase from about 60% in the early 1970s to 66%-67% in the early 1990s. Then the number leveled off. Now we are seeing that number decrease. Also note we are just starting to see the beginning of the baby boomer retirements. That means that since the early 1970s we have seen the expansion of the number of people who were working (the baby boomers going to work) and now we are seeing the beginning of the baby boomer's retirement.

Let's add one more element to the mix:


The chart above is the employment to population ratio. Remember the groups from Table A1? This is the total number of employed people divided by the civilian non-institutional population. Here's what is interesting about this chart. There are two areas -- the first from 1945 to 1975 and the second from 1990 to 2010. In the first section the employment/population ration fluctuated between 55% and 58%. In the second area we see the numbers fluctuate between 61% - 64%. In other words, the US economy has gotten used to a larger percentage of the population working. But -- as the baby boomers retire that number will probably drop down. Finally, notice that the chart is approaching the percentages we saw before the baby boomers entered the work force.

So to conclude:

1.) People have not "disappeared from the labor force." In fact, a proper reading of the statistics (and what they mean and measure) indicates a large number of people have voluntarily left the labor force.

2.) The participation rate -- the percentage of employed and unemployed people relative to almost the total US population -- began increasing in the 1970s and has recently started to decrease. This corresponds with the baby boomers entering the workforce and the beginning of the baby boomer's retirement.

3.) The percentage of the population that is working is also decreasing. But that might also be due to the beginning of the baby boomer's retirement.

Is Labor Force Shrinkage Really Bad?

Much has been made about last months .3% drop in the Labor Participation rate and the 843,000 additional people added to those "not in the labor force". The assumption is that this is bad for our economy and yet another sign of the continued economic doom that is upon us. I believe that the drop in the labor force may not be entirely bad and much of it may be a readjustment to our modern economy/reality than something we are going to have to make up once the economic recovery gains steam (whenever that is).

First, an article from Bloomberg details that:
Agency statistics show that 2.57 million people requested benefits, up from the 2.10 million applications received during the previous 12 months. That’s an increase of 465,000, or 47 percent higher than the expected rise.


This makes sense and shows us how we can explain away 2.5 million of the 3.4 million person rise in those not in the labor force since December of 2008. You see the BLS shows us that:
The sum of the employed and the unemployed constitutes the civilian labor force. Persons not in the labor force combined with those in the civilian labor force constitute the civilian noninstitutional population 16 years and over. (There is no upper age limit.)


There is in fact no upper age limit to the household survey and thus retirees are counted as "not in the labor force". It is no wonder this number has been rising and the participation rate has been shrinking, as the boomers are just now getting to an age where they have the ability to retire. So, as this graph shows
partrate

Just as the boomers (and women) entering the workforce increased the participation rate from the 70's to the 90's, it is quite likely (and expected) that the boomers retiring will also cause the participation rate to decline sharply going forward.

The "Great Recession" has likely (as referenced by the Bloomberg article above) caused many boomers that lost jobs to take an early retirement (I know several who did this personally) and thus they drop from members of the labor force, to those not in the labor force. This also explains why the number of those not in the labor force who want a job only increased by 800,000 last year while the not in the labor force number was up by 3.4 million. Notice how when we subtract the 2.57 million retirees from the 3.4 million who left the labor force, we end up with almost exactly the 800,000 increase in those not in the labor force who want a job? (the data for these calculations came from the December Jobs Report )

So, what we have going on here appears to be a mass (forced) early retirement exodus that is going on in the US that also coincides with the beginning of the much anticipated baby boomer exodus from the work place. This trend is something that is likely to continue even after the economy recovers, which in theory should a)potentially enable faster reductions in the unemployment rate once job growth begins and b)blunt the impact of future efficiency gains, as retirements may be able to cover job losses.

Just to conclude, what we have here is not some conspiracy theory of people "vanishing" from the labor force, but a large move to early retirement by boomers (albeit pressured by the recession).

Market Mondays



A.) The really big moves for the SPYs last week came pretty quickly -- from Thursday's close to about 10AM in Monday. During this time prices moved about 2 points. In other words, the new year started with a bang.

Trend lines B and C contained the price action for most of the week. Bust notice the price action was higher.

D.) Prices used the 200 minute EMA as technical support for the entire week.



A.) Like the SPYs, the IWMs had a big move higher from Friday's close to about 10 AM on Monday.

After that move, prices were contained between two trend lines. However, unlike the SPYs these containment lines were horizontal rather than upward sloping. As a result, the IWMs were somewhat stagnant for most of the week.

D.) Prices did move higher at the end of trading on Friday, as they broke through upside resistance.

Friday, January 8, 2010

The Seasonal Adjustment

From Bonddad: SilverOz also wrote on this here. Also, the Census Bureau has a great explanation of seasonal adjustments here.

Bonddad asked me to write a little bit on the seasonal adjustment for December, as the adjustment used this month was significantly larger (to the downside) than in previous years for this month. This large downward adjustment to the seasonal adjustment (I am discussing the Establishment Survey here) is a bit inexplicable, as the typical seasonal factor that is attributed to the downward adjustment is Christmas hiring, which is fairly stable over time and if anything was weaker this year. Thus, it may be that after last year's huge revisions (coming to an employment report in February) the BLS decided to err on the side of conservatism and overestimate the seasonal adjustments instead of underestimating them (because presumably no one will publish conspiracy theories about the BLS "cooking the books" if the numbers are revised up at the end of the year).

To quickly look at the data behind my theory, I will look at the December adjustments, as these were the most "off" from their averages (or even from 2008). In December, the difference can be seen in comparison to both the average and the 2008 adjustment, as the historical adjustment is -.56 versus the -.69% used by the BLS in 2009, which would yield a jobs difference of 171,000 (netting a positive jobs number for December), however the 2008 adjustment was -.62%, which would take us to a positive 7,000 jobs for the month. The interesting thing about this large downward change in the seasonal adjustment for December is that the large seasonal factor for the month (ie Christmas Jobs) was consistent in its adjustment with previous years (subtracting 545,000 jobs from the report), meaning that the additional adjustment came from a sector outside of retail.

So, what we will really have to watch closely is the January job numbers to see what changes to the seasonal adjustment are made then, as it would seem highly suspect to subtract extra seasonal jobs in December and then not add back to account for the seasonal firing in January/February. It may very well be that the BLS has tweaked their adjustments to a more conservative number (ie less jobs) in order to avoid any future embarrassing revisions like will take place next month.

Weekly Indicators (and special bonus: can Mish count?)

- by New Deal democrat

Well, we all know what the Big Story was this week. I am pleased to advise that the Emperor has graciously allowed me a reprieve to await the final revisions for December and January before I must commit ritual Seppuku.

There is clearly a disconnect between the ISM indices and everything else. Neither the direction nor the intensity of the changes in either ISM index have correlated with either the ADP or BLS data in the last few months. Anyway, turning to the weekly data ...

The BLS also reported 434,000 initial jobless claims filed. The four week moving average continues to improve, at just over 450,000.

The weekly data for both the ICSC and Shoppertrak showed impressive gains, as did the monthly ICSC retail numbers. The ICSC reported December retail sales up 2.8% vs. last year. For the week, they were up 2.5% YoY and 1.5% WoW. Shoppertrak showed YoY sales up 15.3% and WoW sales up 27.5%.

Oil moved up over $80 a barrel, and gasoline up to $2.67/gallon, which does not bode well for later this year. Usage remained slightly ahead of a year ago.

Railfax showed a typical end of the year slump. Cyclical and intermodal data are running ahead of last year (consistent with the post-2001 recovery), but the "baseline" data is less -- which is intriguing.

The Daily Treasury Statement gives us a first: as of January 6, 2010 withholding taxes paid, at $40.0B, are ahead of 2009 taxes paid, which were $38.7B.
___________________

Finally, as a special bonus: the breathless headline on Mish's blog today reads: Jobs Contract 24th Straight Month; Unemployment Rate Stays At 10.0%

Ummmmmm... according to the BLS, November's jobs report was revised to a +4,000 jobs. Which, technically speaking, would make December the "first straight month" of job contraction.

Happy weekend, everybody!

Establishment Jobs -85,000; Unemployment Rate Steady at 10%

From the BLS:

Nonfarm payroll employment edged down (-85,000) in December, and the unemployment rate was unchanged at 10.0 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Employment fell in construction, manufacturing, and wholesale trade, while temporary help services and health care added jobs.


Here are the charts:


We can break down the establishment job's data into three parts. First, we had the massive job losses of late 08/early 09. Throughout 2009 the pace of job losses has declined. Finally, since September of last year, we've seen the pace of job losses moderate to the 50,000-150,00 range.


As for the unemployment rate, notice that it is moderating as well. It has been in the 9.5% - 10% range since the summer.

Let's look at the internals.

The big hits came in goods production industries, which lost 81,000, while service jobs lost 4,000. Construction lost 53,000 and manufacturing lost 27,000. On the service side we saw losses in leisure and hospitality (-25,000) and government work (-21,000), but increases in professional (50,000) and and education health care (35,000). And we again saw in increase in temporary employment of 47,000, bringing total gains in this leading to 166,000 since July.

Hours of work and overtime were unchanged and average hourly earnings were higher.

The headline number is a disappointment. However, it's important to remember that economic numbers do not move in straight lines. There have been speed bumps as the jobs situation has developed for the better over the last year. So far, this looks to be that as well.

Forex Fridays


Note the really big volume spike in the dollar ETF in late November. Also note the big volume increase after the rally started.

A.) This is a very strong downward sloping trend line, which

B.) Prices broke through in mid-December.


A.) After rallying, prices are currently in a downward sloping pennant pattern.

B.) The EMA picture is very bullish -- the shorter EMAs are above the longer EMAs, all the EMAs are rising and prices are currently above all the EMAs.


A.) Momentum has given a sell signal. Also note

B.) That volume is moving in and out of the security pretty quickly -- traders are not sticking around but instead are dumping the security on a moment's notice.

Thursday, January 7, 2010

BLS: Economy shed -85,000 jobs in December

The bleeding of jobs during the Great Recession continued in December to the tune of (- 86,000) (subject to revisions - more on that later) after adding a revised +4,000 jobs in November.
So the Recovery remains "jobless" for at least one more month.

[Note: the graphs below do not include this morning's data, but are current through last month. I will substitute the December graphs as soon as they become available]

I. After gaining jobs for two months, services (where 85% of Americans work) were reported to have lost (- 4,000). Job gains were reported in professional positions +50,000, including both health and education. Retail showed a gain of +4,000. Temporary jobs - typically added while employers wait to see if the economic improvement is more sustainable - went up for the 5th month in a row, by +47,000.
The BLS report continues to track reasonably close to the private ADP survey, and out of line with the private ISM manufacturing and non-manufactuing surveys.
Manufacturing lost (-27,000) jobs. Construction, in the epicenter of the economic downturn, continued to shed jobs at (- 53,000), mirroring the lackluster performance of home sales and the continuing plunge in nonresidential construction.
This is generally a continuation of the trend that began two months ago, when services jobs (red in the graph below) first showed growth in the payrolls report, but goods producing jobs (manufacturing + construction) (blue in the graph below)were still negative (a pattern seen at the end of past recessions).


As many of you already know, in fact there are two surveys -- the "establishment" survey which polls businesses, and has received much criticism for its "birth/death" adjustment; and the "household" survey, conducted by the Census Bureau, which polls households, and does not have any such adjustment. The two do not measure the exact same thing (e.g., self-employment is not counted by the BLS), but track each other closely over time. Typically the household survey turns simultaneously with or one or two months ahead of the establishment survey.
The household survey (blue in the graph below vs. red for the establishment survey) turned positive last month, but this month returned to (-589,000).

This means the household survey has not yet turned.

II. The other big number reported this morning is the unemployment rate, which remained at 10.0%.

The alternative U6 number rose slightly from 17.2% to 17.3%This is in large part a reflection of the fact that discouraged workers continue to leave the economy. The labor participation rate (how many people participate in the jobs economy) fell to 64.6%. Keep in mind that the unemployment rate is the last thing to turn positive in an economic recovery.

III. While the above are the headline numbers, there are other aspects of the report that are also very noteworthy. The aggregate number of hours worked in the economy bottomed in Ocotber, improved in November, and remained the same in December.

This means that in addition to hiring, hours of work are also increasing. It is also a measure relied on in part by the NBER to date the end of Recessions.


Another noteworthy item is the average number of hours worked in manufacturing. This is one of the 10 Leading Economic Indicators I refer to. It turned up back in the summer, and is an item I said to watch in terms of the possibility of a V-shaped recovery. It has risen substantially since then, but remained even at 40.4 hours from November to December:



One more statistic thought to lead employment is hours worked in overtime, as typically employers will add to overtime in their workers before they hire new ones. This also reamined the same at 3.4 hours:



The overall average workweek, which includes services and other jobs as well, remained constant at 33.2 hours:



Hourly earnings also increased 0.2%, in line with expectations.


At least on a temporary basis, this is a discouraging report. Expectations were for essentially a 0 number this month. Remember I mentioned at the beginning the upward revision into positive territory of November? That was the 8th time in 9 months that the initial report had been revised higher. I recall the Septemeber report which was initially seen as a very discouraging (-269,000) jobs lost, but two months later was revised to (-175,000). The forward looking parts of this report continue to show improvement (more temporary hiring) or remained intact (overtime, manufacturing hours). The payroll series is notoriously noisy, and the trend -- which is obviously even if we just average over 2 months -- remains that jobs will be added shortly.

Back in September, I said that it was likely that jobs would bottom in November or December, +/- 1 month. While it may be proven false in a month or two, I believe that it remains a reasonable forecast.

Today's Market




On both charts above, notice that prices are poised to move higher in the event of a good jobs number. Both have positive momentum and volume inflows. Both have recently moved through key resistance levels as well. Now all we need is a good jobs numbers

Pre-BLS Numbers, Pt. 2

Earlier today NDD emailed me and asked me to add some charts to the story below (he was away from his computer). I thought the story was fine, but he pressed on. So, I pulled up the ADP employment report which I had never really looked at. So first, let's look at the ADP/BLS comparison.

It's important to remember one big difference between ADP and the BLS: ADP does not include government employees. But with that in mind, notice that in general ADP tracks the BLS' numbers. They seem to jockey for overall position, but in general move in the same direction.

Let's look at ADP in more detail.



First, notice the ADP and BLS reports generally track each other.



The BLS has service employment increasing last month by 58,000. In the latest ADP survey we see an increase of 12,000. So these series agree that service industries are starting to hire again.

As NDD points out, this is in contrast to the ISM service report which had this to say in its latest report:

Employment activity in the non-manufacturing sector contracted in December for the 23rd time in the last 24 months. ISM's Non-Manufacturing Employment Index for December registered 44 percent. This reflects an increase of 2.4 percentage points when compared to the 41.6 percent registered in November. Four industries reported increased employment, 12 industries reported decreased employment, and two industries reported unchanged employment compared to November. Comments from respondents include: "Decrease in occupancy equals decrease in employment" and "Continuing to aggressively manage costs down."

The industries reporting an increase in employment in December are: Other Services; Retail Trade; Finance & Insurance; and Public Administration. The industries reporting a reduction in employment in December — listed in order — are: Arts, Entertainment & Recreation; Real Estate, Rental & Leasing; Mining; Management of Companies & Support Services; Information; Wholesale Trade; Transportation & Warehousing; Accommodation & Food Services; Construction; Utilities; Health Care & Social Assistance; and Professional, Scientific & Technical Services.


The logical conclusion from the ISM report in relation to the BLS/ADP report is the 4 industries that are hiring did so in greater numbers than the 12 that were reporting a decrease in employment. Note that this ISM report is for December (the holiday season) and one of the areas of hiring was retail employment. However, also note that finance and insurance were hiring in the ISM survey and that "professional and business service" employment increased by 86,000 in the BLS survey. In short, it appears as though the professional services sector is very important right now.

In contrast, manufacturing employment is still in the dumps:



But it's important to place this number in historical perspective with two other data points. First, here is a chart of total manufacturing jobs going back to 1979:


Notice that after the last recession we lost about 2.5 million manufacturing jobs that never came back. However --


Overall production (the red line with the arrow underneath it) continued to increase during the 2001 expansion. In other words, the US was making more "stuff," only with fewer people. I would expect that trend to continue after this expansion as well. This means we have two choices regarding the displaced manufacturing workers. Either get more manufacturing business going or retrain them.

However, the BLS and ADP data is in contrast with the ISM Manufacturing survey:

ISM's Employment Index registered 52 percent in December, which is 1.2 percentage points higher than the 50.8 percent reported in November. This is the third month of growth in manufacturing employment, following 14 consecutive months of decline. An Employment Index above 49.7 percent, over time, is generally consistent with an increase in the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data on manufacturing employment.

Seven of the 18 manufacturing industries reported growth in employment in December in the following order: Apparel, Leather & Allied Products; Printing & Related Support Activities; Petroleum & Coal Products; Paper Products; Transportation Equipment; Machinery; and Electrical Equipment, Appliances & Components. The eight industries that reported decreases in employment during December — listed in order — are: Wood Products; Textile Mills; Miscellaneous Manufacturing; Nonmetallic Mineral Products; Plastics & Rubber Products; Food, Beverage & Tobacco Products; Chemical Products; and Fabricated Metal Products.

In order to coordinate this data with the BLS/ADP data, the logical conclusion is that the number of employers shedding jobs (8 industries) are doing so at a faster rate than those that are adding jobs (7 industries).

Finally, we have initial unemployment claims:


Back in the late spring/early summer, this was one of the first economic numbers that got me thinking the worst was over. Well, it is still moving in the right direction.

Taking all the data into consideration we get the following points:

1.) Service are employment is increasing, despite the numbers from the ISM non-manufacturing survey.

2.) Manufacturing employment is probably going through another round of attrition. That is,, manufacturers are using the current downturn to again shed workers.

3.) Initial unemployment claims continue to move lower.



A Look At Treasury Yields



Click for a much larger image

This is from Singer's Market. Notice the clear implication that Treasury yields are forming a complex head and shoulder's pattern and that rates will soon be moving higher.

This is in line with the general Treasury market consensus regarding the Treasury market this year -- that yields are moving higher.