- by New Deal democrat
The monthly personal income and spending report is now the most important report of all, except for jobs. That’s becuase it tells us so much about the state of the consumer economy. It is the raw material for several important coincident indicators that the NBER looks at, as well as several leading indicators on the spending side.
This month’s report for September was absolutely solid if not stellar, as every single important number was positive.
To begin with, nominal personal income rose 0.3%, and spending rose 0.5%. After adjusting for PCE inflation, which rose 0.2%, the former increased 0.1%, and the latter rounded to a gain of 0.4% (graph normed to 100 just before the pandemic). Both are at all-time highs:
In historical terms, spending on goods tends to rise more during the early part of an expansion, and be overtaken by real spending on services in the latter part of an expansion. Additionally, spending on services tends to rise even during recessions. So the more important component to focus on is real spending on goods. This rose a strong 0.7%. Meanwhile - par for the course - real spending on services increased 0.2%. Again, both made another all-time high:
On a YoY growth basis, real spending on services remains slightly higher than real spending on goods, at 3.2% vs. 2.8%.
Prof. Edward Leamer’s business cycle model indicates that spending on durable goods (dark blue, left scale) tends to peak first, before nondurable or consumer goods (light blue, right scale). In September the former rose 0.4%, and the latter 0.8% in real terms, yet again both at all time highs (the former excepting the two binge-spending stimulus months in 2021):
As indicated above, PCE inflation rose +0.2% for the month. On a YoY basis, PCE inflation is 2.1%, the lowest since February 2021 and only slightly higher than its average during the five years before the pandemic:
To reiterate a point I’ve made many times, with the exception of shelter costs in the CPI, the Fed’s inflation target has really been met.
While it wasn’t a negative, if there was a slight blemish in this report it was that the saving rate declined -0.2% to 4.6%. This compares with January’s recent high of 5.5%. The below graph subtracts -4.6% so that the current reading shows at the zero line, indicating that the current rate is now a little below the average rate in the decade before the pandemic:
The willingness to spend more and save less in a lower inflation environment speaks to consumer confidence. On the other hand, it does leave consumers a little more vulnerable to an adverse economic shock.
Finally, as indicated above this report goes into the calculation of two important coincident indicators. The first is real personal income less government transfer payments. This rose 0.1%, still another all-time record:
Second, with the usual one month delay, real manufacturing and trade sales rose less than 0.1%, rounding to unchanged, nevertheless ever so slightly at a new all-time record:
This was the third excellent report in a row, and blows away any speculation that the economy might not be still expanding. The only soft spots were real spending on goods, which continues to grow slightly less than for services, suggesting we are later than halfway through this expansion; and the slight decline in the personal saving rate. Everything else was, well, just fine.
