Wednesday, April 8, 2020

The superiority of stay at home orders vs. voluntary social distancing: two graphic proofs



 - by New Deal democrat

Here are a couple of graphs I pulled last week that I’ve been meaning to post. Together they show that mandatory “stay at home” orders have been much more effective than voluntary social distancing.

First, here is a graph of the “change in distance traveled” by county during March:


While almost all counties showed a sharp decline in the average distance travelled - the average decline in counties with only voluntary “social distancing orders” was about -66%, while the average in counties with a mandatory “stay at home” order was over 80%.

Second, here is a graph of the average decline compared to normal distance traveled during the latter part of March:



This graph largely overcomes the “retail desert” critique that people in rural areas must travel long distances to, e.g., the nearest grocery store, since it is a companison against *normal* travel in that area. Note that rural areas like West Virginia, parts of Indiana, and northern Michigan show a much sharper decrease in travel than areas in the South and Great Plains that were not under mandatory “stay at home” orders as of March 26 when the data was gathered.

It is not surprising that the sharp deceleration in the day by day increases in the number of infections happened once mandatory stay at home orders were issued. Since most of Dixie promulgated such orders within the past week or so, further deceleration is likely given the 2 week incubation period for the coronavirus.

Coronavirus dashboard for April 8: peak new infections *may* have occurred on April 4



 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 7) 

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +31,480 to 368,449 (vs. 33,787 possible peak on April 4) 

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 9% (vs. 11% for the past week, and 9% on April 6)

The exponential growth rate began to fall from 35% on March 24. It now looks like in the past week or so it is in a new, decelerating trend, declining by about -1%/day. Here’s a good graph of that trend:
State lockdowns appear to be working.
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 12,621, up +1,941 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 18% day/day vs. average of 17% in past week
  • Number of tests: 146,105 down -8,958  vs. 155,063 on April 6 day/day
  • Rate: decrease -6% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 16,557 vs. 17,292 on April 5 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +9% vs. Tests -6% day/day
Result: The rate of testing appeared to be catching up a little bit to the spread of the virus, but may have stalled again in the past few days. It remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day.

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 146,105 new tests vs. 31,363 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 4.7:1 

In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 4.7:1 is still far behind.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no changes in past 24 hours
  • ***Total lockdown: (SC joined yesterday) 43 States, 306.7 million, 92.4%
  • ***Business lockdown: 2 States (KY, MA) 14.4 million, 4.3%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND^, NE, UT*, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State
There have been no meaningful changes in the past day.
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • Under development: 4 States: CT, MA, NJ, NY

Summary for April 8
Almost every public health authority who has weighed in has advocated the “Sledgehammer, then Scalpel” approach of a temporary total lockdown, during which time, as the infection rate of growth hopefully moves to flat, the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment is surged. Once enough is in place, a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine” can be put in place as the lockdown is lifted.

Here’s how we stand: 
  • Almost 95% of the total US population is under total lockdown.
  • Mandatory lockdowns, first implemented on Statewide bases 19 days ago, appear to be paying off, as the daily rate of increase in new cases has steadily declining and is now in single digits. The peak in new daily infections might only be about 10 days away - and may possibly have already happened on April 4.
  • The number of daily tests appears to have stalled again at about 140-150,000, and is far short of of what is necessary. As a result, we may be missing an increasing number of actual new infections.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so.
  • California’s governor has announced a plan for the States to coordinate in making purchases of the necessary equipment.
  • Massachusetts has begun to develop its own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. The governor of Connecticut announced yesterday that it, NY and NJ will also work on a regional plan.
  • Until States or the federal government implement a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine,” lockdowns cannot be lifted.
  • Contrarily, in States with no lockdowns, Iowas’s governor called for a day of prayer; and North Dakota implemented a quarantine of travelers from Minnesota.

Tuesday, April 7, 2020

Coronavirus dashboard for April 7: lockdowns appear to be working


 - by New Deal democrat


Here is the update through yesterday (April 6) 

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +30,516 to 368,449 (vs. +25,688 on April 4)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 9% (vs. 12% for the past week, and 8% on April 4)

The exponential growth rate began to fall from 35% on March 24. It now looks like in the past week or so it is in a new, decelerating trend, declining by about -1%/day. Voluntary social distancing was clearly not enough, but the State lockdowns appear to be working.
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 10,680, up +1,182 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 12% day/day vs. average of 16% in past week
  • Number of tests: 155,063, up +16,838  vs. 138,225 on April 5 day/day
  • Rate: increase +12% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 17,292 vs. 17,307 on April 5 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +9% vs. Tests +12% day/day
Result: The rate of testing is catching up a little bit to the spread of the virus. Nevertheless, it remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day. Note this target number increases as the number of new infections increases.

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 155,063 new tests vs. 29,023 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 5.3:1 


In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 5.3:1 is still far behind.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions
  • ***Total lockdown: (SC joined yesterday - not shown on map below) 43 States, 306.7 million, 92.4%
  • ***Business lockdown: 2 States (KY, MA) 14.4 million, 4.3%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND, NE, UT*, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD*) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State


US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • Under development: 1 State: MA

Summary for April 7
Almost every public health authority who has weighed in has advocated the “Sledgehammer, then Scalpel” approach of a temporary total lockdown, during which time, as the infection rate of growth hopefully moves to flat, the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment is surged. Once enough is in place, a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine” can be put in place as the lockdown is lifted.

Here’s how we stand: 

  • South Carolina finally went to Statewide lockdown yesterday.
  • Almost 95% of the total US population is under total lockdown.
  • Mandatory lockdowns, first implemented on Statewide bases 18 days ago, appear to be paying off, as the daily rate of increase in new cases has steadily declining and is now in single digits. The peak in new daily infections might only be about 10 days away.
  • The number of daily tests has continued to improve, but is still far short of of what is necessary.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns, or to assist States to do so.
  • Massachusetts has begun to develop its own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. Hopefully this will be adopted by other States quickly.
  • California’s governor has announced a plan for the States to coordinate in making purchases of the necessary equipment.
  • Until States or the federal government implement a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine,” lockdowns cannot be lifted.

The “second order chaotic system” of human behavior at work: previous horrific projections have changed behavior enough that the peak in infections might only be 10 days away


 - by New Deal democrat


Forecasting of human behavior is a “second order chaotic system.” If humans know you are observing them, they observe right back. The conclusions of your study go into a feedback loop causing the humans to change their behavior to what they hope to be a more desirable result for them.

Put another way, it helps to think of humans as incredibly crafty chimpanzees. Put an obstacle in their way, and they will find a way around it. 

So it is with the modeling of coronavirus outcomes. Based on the uncontrolled growth of the virus to date, in mid-March the Imperial College in London put out the following graph of the expected trajectory and deaths in both the UK and the US:  



This death rate accompanied over 20 million infections at the peak alone in early summer:



These graphs were so scary that both countries changed their approaches. In the case of the US, most importantly States started to enact emergency “stay at home” measures. Now that those measures have been in place long enough, they have had a pronounced effect on the expected growth in infections. 

Back on March 23, when Trump was indicating that he would decide about removing “social distancing” restrictions 15 days later - on April 5 - I wrote up a projection of the then-current rate of 34.6% day/day exponential growth in coronavirus infections. 

The daily projections I came up with are reproduced below, together with the actual number of new cases and more importantly, the daily rate of growth on the right:

Mar 22: 36,001         35,224 +32%
Mar 23: 48,458.       46,450 +32%
Mar 24: 65,224.        55,225 +19%
Mar 25: 87,792.        69,197 +25%
Mar 26: 118,168.      86,012 +24%
Mar 27: 159,054.    104,837 +22%
Mar 28: 232,219.    124,686 +19%
Mar 29: 312,567.    143,055 +15%
Mar 30: 420,715.    164,610 +15%
Mar 31: 566,283.    189,633 +15%
Apr 1:    762,217.    216,722 +14%
Apr 2: 1,025,944.    245,722 +13%
Apr 3: 1,380,920.    278,601 +13%
Apr 4: 1,858,719.    312,245 +12%
Apr 5: 2,501,836.    337,933 +8%

Beginning March 23 for the next week, the rate of daily growth on average declined by -2%. Since about March 30 it has declined by -1%. At the current rate of deceleration, about 11 days later (i.e., April 16) there will be no net growth in cases, with a total of about 525,000 cases at that time.

Had the previous rate of growth continued, by April 5 there would have been about 50,000 deaths “baked in the cake.” Instead we crossed the line to over 10,000 yesterday, with a daily rate of growth that has slowed over the past two weeks from over 30% past 24% and about 20% in the past few days. If this rate of decrease likewise were to continue, in two weeks there might only have been about 25,000 deaths from the virus.

As a result, the latest model from the University of Washington shows a peak in hospital use on April 15:



It also shows total deaths through summer between 50,000 and 140,000, with a median likelihood of 80,000:


This is a second order chaotic system at work.  In that regard, it is important to note that this projection depends on lockdowns continuing as long as necessary. But if the optimistic scenario holds, expect humans to want to jump the gun and declare victory, and decrease social distancing.

We really need to see a mass increase in the supplies and tech necessary to implement a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” regimen that will allow lockdowns to be at least partially relaxed.

Monday, April 6, 2020

Revisiting a prediction of exponential growth


 - by New Deal democrat

A few weeks ago, I mentioned that:

“Looking back over my private correspondence, I see where I first voiced the likely impact back on February 27. Here’s what I wrote then:
——-
“The CDC only has 250 working test kits. They have *none* to spare to check for community spread. Thus the virus will spread for several weeks undetected until tests are administered among the first very sick. By then it will be too late.
....
“In short, malpractice by the Buffoon in chief could easily lead to tens of thousands of unnecessary deaths.”
——
Today, April 6, 2020, the US has surpassed 10,000 coronavirus deaths. 

By way of contrast, South Korea, which recorded its first coronavirus case on the same day as the US, has only 186 deaths.

Trump has the blood of 10,000 unnecessary US deaths on his hands. And we’re still nowhere near the midpoint of this virus.

Lockdowns work II


 - by New Deal democrat

Several weeks ago Italy was the poster child for an out-of-control pandemic. It implemented a strict nationwide lockdown. Here are its daily number of new infections:


Next came Spain, which overtook Italy in the total number of infections. It also implemented a nationwide lockdown. Here are its daily number of new infections:



Within the US, Washington State started a local lockdown almost immediately, and was among the first to start a Statewide lockdown. Here are its daily number of new infections, which have plateaued at about 75 per 1 million per capita:


The State of California as a whole was one of the first three States to go to a Statewide lockdown 16 days ago. Here are its daily number of new infections, which plateaued at about 35 per 1 million population (the spike on the last day is probably due to clearance of a huge backlog in. Testing):


Hawaii, besides lockdowns, being islands, started a ban/quarantine on incoming visitors. Here are its daily number of new infections:


Finally, here is the US as a whole. As more and more State lockdowns take effect, the increase in the number of new cases has been slowing: 


Here is a graph from Kevin Drum showing the daily rate of increase of new infections for the US:


Obviously they aren’t the only answer, because aggressive testing, tracing, and quarantine of those in contact with new cases must be implemented for a successful regimen, but the fact is, lockdowns work. The sooner they are implemented, the sooner the daily number of new infections peak.

Coronavirus dashboard for April 6: lockdowns appear to be working


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 5) 

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +25,688 to 337,933 (vs. +33,787 on April 4) 

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 8% (vs. 13% for the past week, and 12% on April 4)

The exponential growth rate began to fall from 35% on March 24. It now looks like in the past week or so it is in a new, decelerating trend, declining by about -1%/day. Voluntary social distancing was clearly not enough, but the State lockdowns appear to be beginning to  work (more on that in a separate post).
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 9,498, up +1,184 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 14% day/day vs. average of 20% in past week
  • Number of tests: 138,225, down -88,720  vs. 226,945 on April 4 day/day
  • Rate: decrease -39% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 17,307 vs. 15,573 on April 4 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +8% vs. Tests -39% day/day
Result: April 4’s high testing number was the result of the 2/3’s clearance of a huge backlog. The rate of testing is catching up a little bit to the spread of the virus. Nevertheless, it remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day. Note this target number increases as the number of new infections increases.

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 138,225 new tests vs. 26,553 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 5.2:1 

In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 5.2:1 is still far behind.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions - no change in past 24 hours
  • ***Total lockdown: 42 States, 301.6 million, 90.9%
  • ***Business lockdown: 3 States (KY, MA, SC*) 16.6 million, 5.0%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND, NE, UT*, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State

There have been no meaningful changes in the past day.
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • Under development: 1 State: MA

Summary for April 6
Almost every public health authority who has weighed in has advocated the “Sledgehammer, then Scalpel” approach of a temporary total lockdown, during which time, as the infection rate of growth hopefully moves to flat, the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment is surged. Once enough is in place, a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine” can be put in place as the lockdown is lifted.

Here’s how we stand: 

  • There were no meaningful changes today in governmental responses.

  • Almost 95% of the total US population is under total lockdown.
  • Mandatory lockdowns, first implemented on Statewide bases 17 days ago, appear to be making a substantial difference, as the daily rate of increase in new cases is steadily declining.
  • Travelers from States that resisted lockdowns until last week (especially Florida!) have probably re-seeded new outbreaks in those that went to lockdowns early. (This will be the subject of a separate post).
  • The number of daily tests has finally improved from about 100,000 to 140,000, but is still far short of of what is necessary.
  • So long as the virus continues to spreading at an exponential rate, the longer it will be until total lockdowns can be lifted.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns.
  • Massachusetts has begun to develop its own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. Hopefully this will be adopted by other States quickly.
  • California’s governor has announced a plan for the States to coordinate in making purchases of the necessary equipment.

Sunday, April 5, 2020

Coronavirus dashboard for April 5: mandatory lockdowns start to work


 - by New Deal democrat


Here is the update through yesterday (April 4) 

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments to the end. 

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below.

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +33,787 to 312,245 (vs. +32,857 on April 3)

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 12% (vs. 34.6% baseline, 14% for the past week, and 13% on April 3)

The exponential growth rate began to fall on March 24. It now looks like in the past week or so it is in a new, decelerating trend, declining by about -1%/day. Voluntary social distancing was clearly not enough, but the State lockdowns appear to be beginning to  work (more on that in a separate post).
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here. Also, there is an awesome interactive tool to measure infections and other data for various countries and US States at 91-divoc.com
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 8,314, up +1,352 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 19% day/day vs. average of 21% in past week
  • Number of tests: 226,945, up +87,332  vs. 139,613 on April 3 day/day
  • Rate: increase of +19% vs. number of tests previous day
  • Tests pending result: 15,573 vs. 61,980 on April 3 day/day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +19% vs. Tests +63% day/day 
Result: The rate of testing had been failing to improve up until the past two days, meaning that we were actually falling further behind. Now we are catching up a little bit. Nevertheless, it remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day. Note this target number is also increasing exponentially as we try to chase the number of exponentially increasing infections.

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 226,945 new tests vs. 33,767 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 6.7:1 

In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 6.7:1 is the best showing yet, but was *very* heavily influenced by the -45,000 decrease in “pending” tests.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions
  • ***Total lockdown: 42 States, 301.6 million, 90.9%
  • ***Business lockdown: 3 States (KY, MA, SC*) 16.6 million, 5.0%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND, NE, UT*, WY^) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR^, SD) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
^restrictions on or quarantine of travelers from out of State
Following Trump’s reversal on Easter Sunday openings, most of the holdout States have implemented lockdowns. There have been no meaningful changes in the past day.
US States with “test, trace, and quarantine” programs
  • Under development: 1 State: MA

Summary for April 6
Almost every public health authority who has weighed in has advocated the “Sledgehammer, then Scalpel” approach of a temporary total lockdown, during which time, as the infection rate of growth hopefully moves to flat, the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment is surged. Once enough is in place, a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine” can be put in place as the lockdown is lifted.

Here’s how we stand: 

  • There were no meaningful changes today in governmental responses.

  • Almost 95% of the total US population is - finally - under total lockdown, with only a few States in the Great Plains, plus Arkansas, Utah, and Wyoming holding out.
  • While “Social distancing” and lockdowns appear to have lowered the growth rate of new infections, they have failed as a method to halt the virus’s spread. 
  • Mandatory lockdowns, first implemented on Statewide bases 16 days ago, appear to be making a difference.
  • Travelers from States that resisted lockdowns until this week (especially Florida!) have probably re-seeded new outbreaks in those that went to lockdowns early. (This will be the subject of a separate post).
  • The number of daily tests has finally improved from about 100,000 to 225,000, but is still short of of what is necessary, particularly since about 40,000 of that improvement was reducing the backlog of “Pending” tests.
  • So long as the virus continues to spreading at an exponential rate, the longer it will be until total lockdowns can be lifted.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, trace, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns.
  • Massachusetts has begun to develop its own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. Hopefully this will be adopted by other States quickly.

Saturday, April 4, 2020

Weekly Indicators for March 30 - April 3 at Seeking Alpha


 - by New Deal democrat

My Weekly Indicators post is up at Seeking Alpha.

This was the week when the bottom finally fell out of almost all the remaining data.

Clicking over and reading will bring you up to the virtual moment on the economy, and reward me a little bit for the effort I put into this endeavor, especially now that I am devoting most of my time to the likely impacts of the coronavirus.

Coronavirus dashboard for April 4: with lockdowns in place, testing still far behind, no action on necessary “test, track, quarantine” plan


 - by New Deal democrat

Here is the update through yesterday (April 3) 

I’ve changed the format, moving the “just the facts, ma’am” data to the top, and comments at the end.

The four most important metrics are starred (***) below. 

Number and rate of increase of Reported Infections (from Johns Hopkins via arcgis.com)
  • Number: up +32,857 to 278,458 (vs. +28,879 on April 2) 

  • ***Rate of increase: day/day: 13% (vs. 34.6% baseline, 15% for the past week, and 13% on April 2)

The exponential growth rate began to fall on March 24, but has not made meaningful progress in 6 days. Also, since testing has fallen further behind, some of the rate of growth may be hidden. Voluntary social distancing failed; we don’t yet know how well the State lockdowns are working.
Ben Engebreth is tracking coronvirus infection and testing numbers for each State, with graphs, here.
Number of deaths and infections and rate of increase of testing (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • ***Number of deaths: Total 5,784, up +1,084 day/day
  • Rate: increase of 9% day/day vs. average of 22% in past week
  • Number of tests: 139,613, up +21,915  vs. 117,698 on April 1 day/day
  • Rate: increase of +19% vs. number of tests previous day
Comparison of rates of increase in documented infections vs. testing  
  • Infections +9% vs. Tests +19% day/day
Result: The rate of testing had been failing to improve up until the past two days, meaning that we were actually falling further behind. Now we are catching up a little bit. Nevertheless, it remains far below what is needed, which is probably now at least 250,000/day. Note this target number is also increasing exponentially as we try to chase the number of exponentially increasing infections. 

Ratio of tests to positives for infection (from COVID Tracking Project)
  • Number: 139,613 new tests vs. 32,906 new diagnosed infections 
  • ***Ratio: 4.3:1 

In South Korea, where aggressive testing has led to a near-total disappearance of new cases, the inflection point where the number of new daily cases plateaued was reached when the ratio of tests to new cases found reached 15:1. Any ratio less than that suggests that not enough testing is being done. Yesterday’s ratio of 4.3:1 continues to show that testing is falling further behind the level of new infections.
US States and population in total lockdown, business lockdown, and partial restrictions
  • ***Total lockdown: 42 States (AL, MO joined in last 24 hours), 301.6 million, 90.9%
  • ***Business lockdown: 3 States (KY, MA, SC*) 16.6 million, 5.0%
  • Partial restrictions on business (bars, restaurants): 5 States (IA, ND, NE, UT*, WY) 9.7 million, 2.9%
  • School closure only: 2 States (AR, SD) 3.9 million, 1.2%
  • No mandatory restrictions: NONE
*some local areas under lockdowns
Here is The NY Times most recent graph (Nebraska has since closed some businesses)
Following Trump’s reversal on Easter Sunday openings, almost all of the holdout States in Dixie have implemented lockdowns. About 95% of the US population is now under stay at home orders.
Summary for April 4
Almost every public health authority who has weighed in has advocated the “Sledgehammer, then Scalpel” approach of a temporary total lockdown, during which time, as the infection rate of growth hopefully moves to flat, the production and distribution of necessary medical equipment is surged. Once enough is in place, a regimen of “test, trace, and quarantine” can be put in place as the lockdown is lifted.

Here’s how we stand:

  • Almost 95% of the total US population is - finally - under total lockdown, with only a few States in the Great Plains, plus Arkansas, Utah, and Wyoming holding out.
  • While “Social distancing” and lockdowns appear to have lowered the growth rate of new infections, they have failed as a method to halt the virus’s spread. 
  • The effect of mandatory lockdowns, first implemented on Statewide bases 15 days ago, is only beginning to be felt.
  • Travelers from States that resisted lockdowns until this week (especially Florida!) have probably re-seeded new outbreaks in those that went to lockdowns early.
  • The number of daily tests has finally improved from about 100,000 to 140,000, but is still probably only half of what is necessary. “Pending” tests of 61,980 are far, far too high.
  • So long as the virus keeps spreading at an exponential rate, even a lower one, we are falling further and further behind, I.e., we are failing to catch more new infections. The longer this continues, the longer it will be until total lockdowns can be lifted.
  • The Trump Administration has still not mandated a nationwide lockdown.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no meaningful steps to mandate mass production of necessary medical equipment.
  • The Trump Administration has taken no steps towards a nationwide “test, track, and quarantine” plan that will be needed to lift lockdowns.
  • The first State I am aware of - Massachusetts - has begun to develop its own “test, trace, and quarantine” plan. Hopefully this will be adopted by other States quickly.