- by New Deal democrat
Along with the employment report, real income and spending are probably the most important monthly reports as to the health of the average American household. But at the moment, for purposes of both the nowcast and the short term forecast, it is probably *the* most important set of data of all, along with stock market prices. That’s because personal consumption, which is about 70% of the entire economy, (at least until this morning’s drastic revisions - much more on that below) appeared currently to be driven by the wealth effect from stock market gains among the uppermost incomes. Unless something else comes out of the shadows to pick up the baton, if and when this wealth effect reverses, and if and when the average consumer pulls back, are the most crucial things to watch for.
Last month I opened my summary by saying that “This year there has been a real split between the income and spending sides of that ledger,” and further indicated that while real spending continued higher and was expansionary, “Real income declined, and continues being recessionary.”
This month that was entirely obliterated by revisions that went back over a year. Suddenly, instead of being negative and recessionary, we find out that consumers have really been basking in the sunshine of record high real incomes all this time. So, for the first time ever, to show you how dramatic the revisions have been, I am re-running last month’s graphs from the personal income side. And it is so jarring that, frankly, for the first time ever, I am waiting to see if there will be leaks from the bureaucracy about political meddling (but this report will give you the numbers straight up as always with a detached eye).
Here’s the more in-depth look.
Real Income:
Nominally income rose 0.2% in August, and was up 4.3% YoY. But after adjusting for the price deflator (blue), which increased 0.3%, they actually declined -0.1% for the month but rebounded to a gain of 0.8% YoY. Further, once we take government transfers into account (red), while the monthly change on a nominal basis was only +0.1%, and a decline -0.1% in real terms, but on a YoY basis they were also up 0.8%. This is in marked contrast with last month, which gave rise to the following graph:
Now here is this month’s updated graph that includes the revisions:
As you can see, the entire weakness since early 2025 is utterly gone.
Here is what the post-pandemic YoY% graph looked like last month:
And here is the updated graph this month:
The negative YoY numbers have vanished.
Real spending:
While the income side of the ledger was suddenly revised to the sunny side of the street, the spending side remained positive also. Nominally spending rose a sharp 0.9% and was up 6.1% YoY, which means that in real terms (blue) it was up 0.6% for the month, and up 2.6% YoY. As I’ve noted many times in the past, the leading indicator in this data has to do with spending on goods (red), as real spending on services (gold) frequently increases all the way through recessions. In August real spending on goods rose 1.3%, and was 2.7% higher YoY, while real spending on services rose 0.2% for the month and is up 2.5% YoY. As you can see, the trend in all three continues to be higher this year compared with last year:
Real spending on durable goods historically tends to peak even before goods spending as a whole. As shown in the below graph, real spending on durable goods (blue) rose 1.9% in August, while real spending on nondurable goods (gold) rose 1.8%:
All of these are at record highs. No sign whatsoever of any weakness here.
Again, the trend this year vs. last year is higher. On a YoY% basis (not shown), real spending on durable goods was higher by 4.6%, and on nondurable goods higher 2.5%.
Savings, real sales, and profits:
The difference between income and spending is what is saved. Once again, the revisions to income were important. Last month, the number was an increase from 2.6% to 3.0%. After revisions, this month for August, the saving rate declined a sharp -0.5%, but revisions meant this was a decline from 4.6% to 4.1%. While this is still very low historically, the saving rate, while low, now is higher than much of the dotcom bubble era as well as the era of the housing bubble and in 2022 (note: graph subtracts -4.1% from the rate to show the current number at the “0” line for easy comparison):
To reiterate: unless and until we see a retrenchment by consumers indicated by a higher savings rate, the party goes on.
Finally, this morning’s report also enables the update of real manufacturing and trade sales, one of the other important coincident markers used by the NBER to date recessions. This was unaffected by the income revisions. They increased 0.6% for July, continuing their uptrend to yet another record high:
They are higher 2.3% YoY (not shown).
To sum up: this morning’s report was an utter blockbuster; but one that relied upon heavy revisions to the last year’s data. While spending is in line with earlier reports, the big hit to real personal income which I have been reporting on all this year has suddenly vanished, replaced with substantial and continuing increases. I will look into the issue of where the revisions came from further, update as necessary if and when I find out anything substantial (probably not until next week).
