- by New Deal democrat
Our data drought won’t end until next Tuesday. In the meantime, let me follow up on a theme from my analysis of the economic data from last week. To wit: there are several metrics that I have already stated are worth a “recession watch;” namely, housing units under construction (down almost 20% from peak), and the 3 month economically weighted ISM new orders subindexes (just into contraction territory at 49.3). Additionally, real aggregate nonsupervisory payrolls look like they may be rolling over. But there are many other measures that are not signaling a recession in the immediate near term (e.g, employment in the goods producing sector).
As I noted several weeks ago, in the past 50+ years, in addition to COVID, almost always there has been a domestic political or geopolitical shock that has precipitated US recessions. There are two excellent candidates — the regressive tax bill just passed by Congress, and Tariff-palooza! - for such shocks. That’s the “fundamentals” view.
But, what data will it take for me to actually go on “recession watch?” And the answer is, at least some of the following continuing or turning negative.
To begin with, several long leading indicators. Last month I updated my look at the non-financial long leading indicators — corporate profits, housing, and real per capita consumption, summing up that “the housing sector is giving recessionary readings. Corporate profits adjusted for inventories are weakening, but are still positive YoY. But real sales are not just positive, but they have been improving.”
Let me update each of the three since then.
First, the last shoes in the housing sector to drop after units under construction but before a recession are housing units for sale in the new home sales report, and employees in residential construction. Here is the long term view of each:
And here is the post-pandemic close-up:
The two measures have tended to peak very close in time to one another. In the last few months there have been signs that both are doing so now. New homes for sale did make a new high - just barely - last month, and the rate of increase has gradually slowed over the last nine months. Meanwhile, employment in residential construction actually declined slightly last month, and has grown less than 0.1% in the past three months.
New home sales will be reported for June in two weeks. I would expect to see a decline before a recession.
While corporate profits for Q2 won’t be reported until the end of August, the proxy of proprietors’ income will be reported at the end of this month. Although this rose in Q1 (not shown) I would expect it to decline before a recession. In the meantime, here is the latest actual (through Q1) and forecast (beginning Q2) S&P 500 earnings from Earnings Insight as of last week:
Usually forecast earnings just before actual reports are too pessimistic, so I expect the Q2 number to improve once actual earnings are in. Companies don’t normally cut staff if profits and sales are increasing, but if there is a 2nd consecutive decline, the likelihood of more layoffs increases.
Another important measure is “real final sales to private domestic purchasers” from the GDP report, which as noted above will be reported at the end of this month. There increased 0.47% in Q1. Here’s how that compares historically pre-pandemic, subtracting 0.47% so that it appears right at the 0 line:
In the past, increases such as we got in Q1 either occurred in times of weak growth - or just before or during a recession.
Here is the post-pandemic view:
If real sales in the GDP report in two weeks are as weak or weaker than in Q1, that would strongly suggest we are on the eve of a recession.
Now let’s look at real consumption as measured by both real retail sales and real spending on goods pre-pandemic, including the latest personal spending report from two weeks ago:
Even without taking into account population growth, real retail sales have tended to flatten or decline months before a recession begins. Here is the post-pandemic update:
Both of these did quite well in 2024, but there are signs that both have been peaking this year. Should both reports continue to go sideways or even decline further, that would suggest that consumers are pulling in their horns.
Finally, I would expect an increase in layoffs. There are signs from continuing jobless claims, as well as the anemic recent nonfarm payrolls growth, that hiring is weakening. Additionally, the comprehensive QCEW census (not shown) has indicated that there was only 0.8% job growth in 2024 rather than the 1.3% officially shown in the un-benchmarked jobs reports. But as I noted yesterday, initial claims are only slightly higher YoY.
Here are several measures of layoffs including not just initial claims, but also layoffs and discharges from the JOLTS report, and the number of short term unemployed, and total unemployed from the jobs report. Here is a historical pre-pandemic look:
The most reliable measure, as above, is initial claims. Additionally, the number of unemployed has generally risen to at least 5% higher YoY several months before a recession has begun. The other two are much more noisy, although they too generally increase.
Here is the post-pandemic record:
As discussed a number of times last year, the increase in several of these numbers likely had to do with the surge of immigrants looking for first time work. This has most likely ended. But I would expect the four week average of initial claims to increase to 10% higher YoY at least in order to justify a recession watch.
In addition a to looking for a downturn in goods producing employment and aggregate real payrolls in the employment report, if all of these either continue weak, or turn weaker, I could conceivably go on “recession watch” for the economy as early as the end of this month.