- by New Deal democrat
The other day a cartoonist named hausofdecline created a little stir on Bluesky with this cartoon:
As you can already see from the two notes above the cartoon, it was quickly dunked on by data types. Here’s a further sample of the pile-on:
Well, your correspondent is one data nerd who will rise to the defense of hausofdecline.
What their cartoon highlights is the difference between the economy *as a whole* and the distribution of gains or losses within the economy. In response to the womans’s complaint that “I can’t afford to feed my family” the “bloodless quant” replies “that’s ludicrous” because “the stock market is at an all time high.”
Touché.
Indeed, the economy *as a whole* IS doing relatively well, especially considering the destructive chaos emanating from Washington. But the stock market helps describe the K-shaped economy.
Let me step back a little bit and put the market in context. One of the data relationships I noticed over a decade ago, and continues to be consistently true is that the stock market, a short leading indicator (blue) does not *anticipate* corporate profits, a long leading indicator (red) so much as it *reacts* to them, especially when averaged on a quarterly basis, shown below for the last 10 years:
Corporate profits in the GDP were last reported for Q1, but so far the indications are that Q2 is going to be another blowout quarter. As the graph below shows, corporate profits have more than doubled in the past 10 years. Measured from just before the pandemic, they have increased on average about 10% *every year.* But even that was outdone by the stock market, which over the same time rose an average of *13%* every year:
In fact, it has been very rate over the past 10 years for the stock market not to have risen over 10% a year, as shown below by subtracting 10% from its YoY performance:
Apropos of my “quick and dirty” forecasting method, the S&P500 has only been negative YoY during periods of economic stress, with recession (caused by the pandemic) or near-recession conditions.
And although there are serious concerns about whether it is approaching or already in a bubble, the advance-decline line (red below) has actually been increasing in the lastest market advance:
Typically when there has been a bubble in the past, the large majority of stocks are declining, with advances concentrated in the bubbly sector.
So yes, the stock market is showing that the economy as a whole is continuing to expand at a decent rate. But while those whose main wealth is tied up in stock ownership have seen it increase by about 14% a year for the past 10 years, by contrast here’s what has happened to house prices compared with income:
Deflated by average nonsupervisory hourly wages, house prices shot up over 20% in the aftermath of the pandemic, and even now are still up over 17% in real terms. And that’s just the price of the house, not accounting for the fact that the monthly mortgage payment in interest alone has doubled, as mortgage rates increased from 3% to 6%. By the way, the same obtains if I deflate by median household income or median usual weekly earnings:
And finally, let me repeat, although I won’t bother with the graph this time, that both real average nonsupervisory wages and real personal income are *down* YoY at present, and aggregate real nonsupervisory payrolls have only risen 0.7% during that time. Something that hausofdecline alluded to in their rebuttal:
I feel a little seen. Is hausofdecline a reader?
My “Weekly Indicators” post is up at Seeking Alpha.
Despite oil prices heading back north of $80/barrel this past week, the underlying fundamentals in all time frames remain positive, including most importantly consumer spending.
As usual, clicking over and reading will bring you up to the virtual moment as to the state of the economy, and reward me with a penny or two for compiling and organizing it for you.