- by New Deal democrat
I have written a lot this year about how the wealth effect from soaring stock market prices has been driving consumer spending, especially among the top-most incomes. It may be a Boom. But if it is a bubble, how soon after it bursts can we expect consumer spending to follow suit?
Unfortunately in the modern era for which we have decent statistics, there is only one example; namely, the dotcom bubble of the late 1990s. In that case, it appears that consumers did not react until it was clear that the bubble had burst, which took several months:
Which is important, because consumer spending, as shown in the YoY% change in real retail sales, below, typically peak on a per capita basis about a year before a recession, and turn negative YoY shortly before it begins:
There has been some choppiness recently, with some AI related stocks actually lagging the headline S&P 500 index (via Carl Quintanilla this morning):
And stocks are only up about 1% from six months ago:
Although on a YoY basis they remain higher by over 10%.
In the past, although it is a commonplace that the stock market anticipates corporate profits, on a quarterly basis the average YoY change in stocks has followed, rather than led, corporate profits. Since FRED isn’t allowed to post the full S&P 500 series, here is the NASDAQ composite going back 50 years compared with corporate profits:
Aside from the 1980s, typically (again, on a quarterly basis averaged), stocks have lagged corporate profits by about one quarter.
Here is the last 10 years, including the S&P 500:
So if the AI data center buildout is a bubble, it will probably show up in earnings first - to which the stock market will then react.
While “official” corporate profits as part of GDP for Q3 won’t be reported until the end of this month, over 90% of the S&P 500 have already reported earnings to Wall Street. Here’s what that looks like:
In Q2, not only did we have the effect of the AI Boom (or bubble), but we also had record profits in the Oil Patch thanks to the surge in prices due to the Iran War. At the moment, reported profits are down about -9% from Q2, although they are higher than any other preceding Quarter. Typically profit estimates for the next several quarters are lower than what the actual results will be - unless a recession starts, in which case all hell breaks loose!
Which brings me back to the current status of retail spending. Here’s what the recent YoY comparison looks like:
No recession risk showing there.
And here is the recent absolute value of real retail sales:
If the AI data center buildout is in fact a bubble, I would expect corporate warnings and substantial misses compared with estimates. Which the stock market will sniff out; and if the sell-off got serious and persistent, then (all else being equal) I would expect consumer spending to follow in short order.
As to which, retail sales for October will be reported tomorrow.








