- by New Deal democrat
I think if I ever decided to cut back my online writing about the economy to the bare bones, it would be two posts a month. The first of the two posts would be this one, because the economically weighted ISM manufacturing + services indexes continue to be the best timely snapshot of the US economy, and the former in particular has an 80 year history (the latter about 25) of being accurate. The second post would be at the end of the month to see how well the other economic data confirmed this average - and while it would be noisy, I would expect it to be largely on target, especially over a three month period.
With that introduction, last week the manufacturing sector for October showed expansion across the board, with a heavy dose of inflation. This morning the services index was updated to the same effect with the slight exception of employment. A reminder that the weighting, based on their impact on the economy, is 25% manufacturing and 75% services. Further, to cut down on monthly noise, I particularly look at the three month averages.
To the numbers: the headline services index declined -0.5 to 54.9 [recall that any number over 50 indicates expansion]. The three month average was 54.8. Since the three month average for manufacturing was 54.9, the economically weighted average was 54.8, a declne of -0.2 from last month [note: in all of the graphs below, the manufacturing number is blue, and services gray]:
New orders declined -1.1 to a still strong 59.8. The three month average was 59.3. The three month average for manufacturing was 55.2, so the economically weighted of this most forward looking component was 58.3, an increase of 1.1 from September:
The relatively punk metric in these indexes has been employment, which has been in contraction for over a year. This month it improved all the way to slightly above neutral, as the services employment subindex rose +2.3 to 50.1. The three month remained contractionary, however, averaging 48.4. Since the manufacturing employment subindex average was 52.2, the economically weighted average was (slightly) below 50 for the third month in a row as well, unchanged at 49.4:
Importantly, although it has been better than summer of last year, the ISM weighted average has only shown expansion in two months this year - February and June - in contrast with the generally positive monthly jobs reports. It is possible that this difference is because these are diffusion indexes, so if slightly less than 50% of industries are hiring, the ISM average would be negative, while if the net actual hiring was more focused on the expanding industries, the nonfarm payrolls number would be positive.
Finally, widespread price increases not only continue to be a problem, but they appear to be worsening, as the prices paid index for services rose +1.4 to 74.0, its highest number in over two years, with the three month average rising 2.1 to 72.3. The three month average for manufacturing rose further this month to 73.4 so the economically weighted average increased 0.2 to 72.6:
This has become almost as bad as during the post-pandemic inflation, with the worst reading since mid-year 2022 (note that unlike the other three graphs, this one shows the last five years for better comparison).
In sum, the economically weighted ISM averages indicate that as of now, the economy remains in reasonably strong expansion. Further, the very positive new orders indexes suggest it might get even stronger. This appears to be bringing along employment, which is essentially neutral and on the cusp of turning (slightly) positive. But along with the increased demand, inflationary pressures are also becoming even stronger; and if inflation is becoming even more widespread at the producer level, can consumer inflation be far behind? Maybe I should call this an even more inflationary even broader expansion.
