- by New Deal democrat
As anticipated, the March CPI packed a wallop, up 0.9% for the month and causing the YoY% gain to increase to 3.3%, while core CPI was a tame 0.2% with a YoY% gain of 2.6%. Because of the impact of that big number, I am departing from my usual format to focus on energy and shelter, but also the impact on real wages and incomes.
But first, and as I’ve written in the past few months, here is an IMPORTANT CAUTIONARY NOTE: Because the October-November kludge in shelter prices of a mere 0.1% increase for two months is still present in the YoY calculations, and will be until this coming November, this is probably continuing to lower those comparisons by roughly -0.2%. In other words, take out that kludge and YoY headline CPI would probably be 3.5%, and core at 2.8%.
First, as per my usual practice for the past several years, let’s start with the YoY numbers for headline inflation (blue), core inflation (red), and inflation ex shelter (gold), which because of the big impact of oil, surged to 3.4% YoY:
Before I go further, let’s note some good news: the very large shelter component of CPI has continued to undergo disinflation. Actual rent was only up 0.1% for the month, the lowest monthly increase since the end of 2020, and up 2.6% YoY, the lowest number since June 2021. Similarly, Owners Equivalent Rent increased only 0.2%, and was up 3.1% YoY. These are also the lowest numbers since late 2020 (except for last September) and late 2021, respectively (Note this is also substantially true even if we apply the counter to the government shutdown kludge):
Further, as I have been writing since way back in 2021 is that the YoY% changes in the repeat home sales indexes lead shelter CPI by about 12-18 months. It did that on the way up, and it has been doing that on the way down. YoY home price increases continue near or at multi-year lows, the FHFA at 1.6%, and Case Shiller’s national index at 0.9%. And shelter inflation has followed, as shown in the graph below:
Shelter inflation has declined to *below* its pre-pandemic YoY range. Needless to say, because of the leading/lagging relationship of house prices to shelter inflation, we can expect even *further* deceleration in the shelter component of inflation during this year.
Let me put this succinctly: if nobody had started a war with Iran, this morning’s report would have been very good news, with the biggest problem child of the past 5 years, shelter, going into hibernation.
But, alas, that is not our world. Here is an update of a graph I put up several weeks ago, showing my K.I.S.S. estimate based on the increase in gas prices (blue), vs. the actual CPI number (red):
Because gas prices started out so low as a share of consumer spending, the increase was not nearly as bad as it could have been; but also, as I pointed out in that analysis several weeks ago, it is common for the effects of an oil shock to show up in the subsequent month (in this case, April) as well.
But now let’s turn to the effect of this oil shock on household finances.
In last week’s jobs report, average hourly wages for nonsupervisory workers increased 0.2%. Now that we know what March inflation was, that means that real wages declined -0.7% in March:
This puts them at their lowest level since last April, and they are now only up 0.1% YoY. As the long term view shows, with the exception of the 1980s and early 1990s, when the massive entry of Boomers and women into the labor force acted to depress wage gains, this often is a harbinger of near term recession:
And the bad news doesn’t stop there. Remember that one of my big forecasting tools is real aggregate nonsupervisory payrolls, showing the amount of $$$ in total that average households have to spend. In March, nominally aggregate nonsupervisory payrolls rose 0.3%. With the inflation adjustment, real aggregate nonsupervisory payrolls declined -0.6%, and are -0.7% below their January peak:
This puts us back to just above where we were last September. Further, as I wrote in the past several weeks, a -0.7% decline from peak in this metric is about the median decline at the onset of past recessions.
Finally, on a YoY% basis, real aggregate nonsupervisory payrolls are only up 0.8%, the lowest since the pandemic:
Historically, outside of the 2002 near-“double-dip”, such a low YoY gain has only a few times outside of recessions, particularly in the case of 1979-80, where it occurred just a few months before, and also several isolated one month downturns (note: graph below adds 0.7% to value so that a 0.8% increase shows at the 0 line):
As suspected before the official numbers, needless to say this was a very poor report. The good news of disinflating shelter costs has been squandered, at least for March. Further, this is a very real loss in average consumers’ finances. By at least one important measure, it is at very least near-recessionary if not outright recessionary. The only silver lining is that this is just one month. If we get lucky and there is not another big increase in April, and further the situation in the Middle East is allowed to settle down sufficiently so that gas prices actually declined somewhat in the next several months, we might escape without more seriously negative consequences.